The 2007–2008 world food price crisis was a sharp rise in the international prices of staple foods, chiefly wheat, maize, rice, soybeans and vegetable oils, that built up through 2006 and 2007 and peaked in the first half of 2008. World market prices for several grains roughly doubled within about two years, and the export price of rice rose even faster in early 2008. Because poorer households spend a large share of their income on food, the rise pushed many millions of people towards hunger and set off protests and riots in dozens of countries.
The episode overlapped with record oil prices and with the early stages of the global financial crisis, and prices fell back in the second half of 2008 as the world economy contracted. Economists still debate how much each of its many causes contributed. The crisis shaped later debates about food security, agricultural trade rules and the regulation of commodity derivatives markets.
How prices moved
After low real prices in the 1980s and 1990s, grain prices began to climb in 2006. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), which publishes a monthly food price index, recorded what was then its highest reading in mid-2008. Wheat futures on the Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT) reached record levels in early 2008, and maize and soybean prices peaked around the middle of the year. Rice saw the most dramatic move. Because most rice is eaten where it is grown, the international market is thin, and export prices roughly tripled between late 2007 and the spring of 2008.
The rise in grain prices fed into consumer inflation around the world, most of all in low-income countries where food weighs heavily in household budgets. Prices dropped steeply in late 2008, and a second spike followed in 2010 and 2011.
Causes
No single cause explains the crisis. Studies by international organisations, central banks and academics usually point to a combination of factors:
- Biofuel demand. US ethanol production, encouraged by the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) created in 2005 and expanded in 2007, and European support for biodiesel diverted maize and vegetable oils from food and feed into biofuel production and drew land away from other crops. Estimates of the size of this effect vary widely.
- Energy and input costs. High prices for crude oil raised the cost of fertiliser, diesel and freight, and tied farm prices more closely to energy markets.
- Weather and low stocks. Drought cut wheat harvests in Australia, a major exporter, while world grain stocks had fallen to low levels relative to consumption, leaving little buffer against shocks.
- Export restrictions. As prices rose, several exporting countries, including major rice exporters such as India and Vietnam, imposed bans, quotas or taxes on shipments. Each export restriction reduced supply on world markets and encouraged precautionary buying by importers.
- The dollar. Most internationally traded commodities are priced in US dollars, and the fall of the US dollar index over the period raised dollar prices by more than prices measured in other currencies.
- Financial investment. Money placed in commodity index funds grew rapidly from the mid-2000s. Some argued that this buying pushed futures prices above levels justified by supply and demand; others found little evidence that index positions caused the price changes.
Effects
The price rise hit net food importers and the urban poor hardest. The World Bank warned in 2008 that higher food prices could push as many as 100 million people deeper into poverty. Protests and riots took place in countries including Haiti, Egypt, Bangladesh and Cameroon; in Haiti, unrest in April 2008 was followed by the Senate voting to remove the prime minister.
The macroeconomic effects were uneven. Countries that export farm goods gained from improved terms of trade, while food-importing countries faced larger import bills, wider current account deficits and pressure on their currencies. Governments responded with subsidies, price controls, tariff cuts, releases from public stocks and, in some cases, further export curbs.
International response
In April 2008 the UN Secretary-General set up a High-Level Task Force on the Global Food Security Crisis. The World Bank created a rapid-financing facility for affected countries, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) expanded lending to low-income countries facing higher food and fuel bills, and emergency food aid was scaled up through the World Food Programme. After the second spike, the G20 launched the Agricultural Market Information System (AMIS) in 2011 to improve data on production, stocks and trade in the main grains and soybeans.
Debate over speculation and regulation
The role of financial speculation became a political issue in the United States in 2008, when congressional hearings examined whether index investors and other non-commercial participants had inflated food and energy prices. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) began publishing more detailed information on index investment, and the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 directed the agency to set limits on speculative positions in physical commodity futures and economically equivalent swaps (see CFTC Position Limits and Trader Reporting). The European Union later introduced position limits for commodity derivatives under MiFID II.
Research since the crisis has not settled the question. Many economists conclude that market fundamentals, policy choices such as biofuel mandates and export bans, and macroeconomic conditions explain most of the movement. Others argue that financial flows added to volatility or amplified short-term spikes in agricultural futures.
External links
Ref 1150000121