Prohibited trading practices in US futures markets are forms of trading conduct banned by the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), by rules of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and by the rulebooks of exchanges such as CME Group and ICE. The best-known is the wash trade, a trade that creates the appearance of activity without any real change in ownership, but the law reaches further.
The practices described here share a common concern: futures prices must come from open and competitive trading, because those prices are used to value positions, settle contracts and price goods worldwide. Accommodation trading and ginzy trading are noncompetitive practices that grew out of the trading pit, while the disruptive practices added by the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010 address conduct in electronic markets, including spoofing. Exchanges police these rules through market surveillance, and the CFTC brings civil cases, with criminal cases possible through the Department of Justice.
Accommodation Trading
Accommodation trading is noncompetitive trading entered into to help another trader carry out a trade that is itself improper, such as a wash trade or an illegal cross trade. The accommodating party takes the other side of the trade, often at a price agreed in advance, knowing that the transaction is not a genuine, competitive one. The CEA names accommodation trades alongside wash sales and fictitious sales as transactions that may not be offered or confirmed on a regulated market.
The ban covers the helper as well as the trader being helped, so a broker or local who fills an order as a favour can be liable even without profiting. Accommodation trades are closely related to prearranged trading, in which buyer and seller agree the terms before a trade reaches the market. Both undermine price discovery because the recorded price does not reflect open bidding.
Disruptive Trading Practice
A disruptive trading practice is conduct banned by Section 4c(a)(5) of the Commodity Exchange Act, a provision added by the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010. The section makes it unlawful to engage in three kinds of conduct on a registered entity:
- Violating bids or offers. Buying at a price above the lowest available offer, or selling below the highest available bid, in a way that disregards the market.
- Disorderly trading at the close. Intentional or reckless disregard for orderly execution during the closing period, the window used to set settlement prices, which overlaps with practices such as banging the close.
- Spoofing. Bidding or offering with the intent to cancel the order before it is executed.
The CFTC published interpretive guidance on the section in 2013. Spoofing cases have since become among the largest enforcement matters in US futures markets, including actions against banks and individual traders.
Ginzy Trading
Ginzy trading is a historical floor practice in which a broker filling an order split it between two prices, trading part at one price and part one tick away, to give the customer an average price that could not be achieved in a single trade at the minimum price increment. The broker would trade with another floor member who agreed to accept the split, so the trade was not exposed to the whole pit.
Because the prices were worked out between two traders rather than through open bidding, ginzy trading was treated as noncompetitive and was banned by exchange rules and pursued as a CEA violation. The practice belonged to open outcry pits, and with the move to electronic trading, where orders are matched by price and time priority, it has largely disappeared. The term survives mainly in enforcement histories and glossaries.
Comparing the practices
| Practice | Legal basis | Main harm |
|---|---|---|
| Accommodation trading | CEA ban on wash, accommodation and fictitious trades | Noncompetitive prices; helps other abuses |
| Disruptive trading practice | CEA Section 4c(a)(5), added 2010 | False signals and disorderly prices |
| Ginzy trading | Exchange rules and CEA noncompetitive-trading bans | Prices set outside open bidding |
All three sit within the wider category of market manipulation and trade-practice violations that exchanges and the National Futures Association (NFA) monitor alongside the CFTC.
External links
Ref 1140000207