Open outcry is a method of trading in which participants stand together on an exchange floor and announce their bids and offers by shouting and by hand signals, so that everyone in the crowd can hear and respond. A trade is made when one person accepts another's price. For more than a century it was the standard way of trading futures and options, and it was used on many stock exchanges as well.
The method has been almost entirely replaced by electronic trading, in which orders are matched by computer. It survives in a few places, mainly for complex options orders and for setting certain reference prices. Exchange rules historically required that all orders in a contract be exposed to the whole floor, which is the sense of "open": no trade was to be arranged privately.
How it worked
Trading took place in a pit or ring, a stepped, usually octagonal area that let each trader see the others. Each contract had its own pit, and traders in different delivery months stood in set parts of it. A bid was called as price then quantity, an offer as quantity then price. Hand signals carried the same information across the noise: palms toward the body meant buying, palms outward meant selling, and fingers showed price and size.
Two kinds of participant met in the pit. A floor broker executed orders for customers and member firms, received by telephone or from clerks at the edge of the floor. A floor trader, known as a local, traded for a personal account, often by scalping small price differences, and in doing so supplied much of the market's liquidity. After a trade, each side recorded the price, quantity and the other's badge on a card, and the records were submitted to the clearing house for matching. Trades that did not match, called out-trades, had to be resolved before the next session.
History
Trading by public outcry is as old as organized markets. The form associated with modern derivatives developed in the grain markets of Chicago in the nineteenth century, at the Chicago Board of Trade, and was adopted by the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and by exchanges in New York, London and elsewhere. When listed options began trading at the Chicago Board Options Exchange in 1973, they too were traded in crowds on a floor.
Decline
Electronic systems appeared alongside the pits in the late 1980s and 1990s, at first for trading outside floor hours. A turning point came in 1998, when trading in German government bond futures moved within months from the London floor to a rival electronic exchange in Frankfurt that offered lower costs. London's financial futures floor closed soon afterward. The International Petroleum Exchange ended floor trading in 2005.
In the United States the shift was slower but as complete. The Chicago and New York futures pits lost nearly all their volume to screens during the 2000s. CME Group closed most of its futures pits in 2015, and the New York energy and metals floor closed at the end of 2016. Floors that remained were shut during the pandemic in March 2020, and most did not reopen.
Advantages and drawbacks
Supporters argued that a crowd of traders in sight of one another was good at price discovery, especially for large or complicated orders, because a broker could gauge interest and negotiate. Floor traders also read information from the behaviour of the pit that a screen does not show.
The drawbacks were cost, capacity and control. A floor needed a building, staff and members physically present, and could handle only as many orders as people could shout. Records were made by hand after the event, so the audit trail was weaker than a computer's timestamped log. That left room for abuses such as front-running customer orders, which were the subject of a federal investigation of the Chicago pits in the late 1980s. Electronic markets are open to anyone with a connection, operate nearly around the clock and match orders in fractions of a second.
Where it survives
A few floors remain. Several United States options exchanges keep them for large and multi-leg orders, including the main pit for S&P 500 index options in Chicago. The London Metal Exchange still uses a ring session of open outcry to establish its official daily prices. The floor of the New York Stock Exchange is a hybrid: most orders are matched electronically, with floor staff active mainly at the opening and closing auctions. In each case the floor handles a small share of total volume.