Performance materiality is the amount, or amounts, set by an auditor at less than materiality for the financial statements as a whole. Its purpose is to reduce to an appropriately low level the probability that the total of uncorrected and undetected misstatements exceeds overall materiality. It may also be set for particular classes of transactions, account balances or disclosures. The concept is defined in ISA 320, Materiality in Planning and Performing an Audit.
Overall materiality, or the audit materiality threshold, answers the question of what size of error would matter to users. Performance materiality answers a practical question: what threshold should be used in detailed testing so that the errors the auditor misses, together with the errors found but not corrected, do not add up to more than overall materiality. For US public companies, the PCAOB uses the related concept of tolerable misstatement.
Why a lower threshold is needed
If the auditor designed every test to detect only misstatements as large as overall materiality, several smaller errors in different accounts could go undetected and, in total, make the statements materially wrong. This is called aggregation risk. Audit procedures are performed on samples and rely on judgement, so some misstatements are always missed; this residual risk is reflected in audit sampling risk and non-sampling risk. Setting a lower working threshold builds in a margin for these undetected and uncorrected amounts.
How it is set
ISA 320 does not prescribe a percentage. In practice, audit firms commonly set performance materiality at between 50% and 75% of overall materiality, using their own methodologies. The calculation is:
- is performance materiality.
- is overall materiality for the financial statements as a whole.
- is the percentage chosen by the auditor, typically from 0.50 to 0.75.
The auditor chooses a percentage towards the lower end when the risk of misstatement is higher, for example:
- A first-year audit, where the auditor has limited knowledge of the entity.
- A history of significant misstatements found in previous audits.
- A weak control environment, or identified internal control deficiencies.
- Significant changes in the business, systems or management, or a high level of estimation in the accounts.
A higher percentage is used for a stable, well-controlled entity with few past errors.
Worked example
Suppose a company reports profit before tax of 40 million, and the auditor sets overall materiality at 5% of that benchmark:
Because this is the second year of the engagement and a few adjustments were found last year, the auditor selects 65%:
Testing is then designed around 1.3 million. The auditor also sets a clearly trivial threshold, below which misstatements need not be accumulated. Under ISA 450 this is an amount below which errors would clearly be inconsequential; many firms use around 5% of overall materiality, here 100,000. A misstatement of 120,000 would therefore be recorded on the schedule of uncorrected misstatements, while one of 40,000 would not.
How it is used
Performance materiality influences the nature and extent of audit work. It feeds into sample size calculations: a lower threshold produces larger samples in tests of detail. It sets the threshold for investigating differences in a substantive analytical procedure, and it helps decide which account balances are significant enough to test. Separate, lower performance materiality may be set for sensitive items, such as related-party transactions or directors' remuneration, where users may care about smaller amounts. In group audits, component auditors work to component performance materiality set by the group engagement team, which is lower than group materiality to allow for aggregation across components.
The level is reviewed during the audit. If actual results differ significantly from those used at planning, or the auditor finds more misstatements than expected, overall and performance materiality may need to be revised and further work carried out, which can change the scope of evidence gathering and the audit risk assessment.
Limitations
Performance materiality is a judgement-based safeguard, not a precise statistical measure, and different firms can reach different figures for similar companies. Qualitative factors mean that some misstatements below the threshold can still be material, for example errors that turn a loss into a profit, affect loan covenant compliance or involve fraud. Regulators have criticised cases where firms set performance materiality at the top of the range without sufficient justification. The figures are rarely disclosed, although UK auditors' reports for some entities describe how materiality and performance materiality were applied, and key audit matter disclosures may refer to them.