A key audit matter (KAM) is a matter that, in the auditor's professional judgement, was of most significance in the audit of the financial statements of the current period. KAMs are described in a dedicated section of the auditor's report, explaining why each matter was significant and how the audit addressed it. They give users a view into the auditor's work beyond the standard pass or fail opinion.
The requirement comes from ISA 701, Communicating Key Audit Matters in the Independent Auditor's Report, issued by the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board as part of a wider reform of auditor reporting. ISA 701 applies to audits of complete sets of general purpose financial statements of listed entities for periods ending on or after 15 December 2016, and to other entities where law requires or the auditor chooses. The US counterpart is the critical audit matter (CAM) required by the PCAOB.
Background
For decades the standard auditor's report was a short, largely boilerplate document. After the financial crisis of 2007 to 2009, investors argued that it said little about the judgements behind an audit, while the auditor knew a great deal about the company's most difficult areas. The United Kingdom moved first, requiring auditors of certain listed companies to describe the assessed risks of material misstatement with the greatest effect on the audit for periods beginning on or after 1 October 2012. The IAASB's new and revised reporting standards followed, and the European Union's audit regulation for public-interest entities, adopted in 2014, also requires a description of the most significant assessed risks.
How key audit matters are selected
ISA 701 sets a filter. The auditor starts with all matters communicated to those charged with governance, usually the audit committee. From these, the auditor identifies matters that required significant auditor attention, taking into account:
- Areas of higher assessed risk of material misstatement, or significant risks identified through audit risk assessment.
- Significant auditor judgements relating to areas of the financial statements involving significant management judgement, including accounting estimates with high estimation uncertainty.
- The effect on the audit of significant events or transactions that occurred during the period.
The matters of most significance among those become KAMs. Common examples include impairment of goodwill under IAS 36, revenue recognition on complex contracts, expected credit loss provisions in banks under IFRS 9, insurance contract liabilities, uncertain tax positions, major acquisitions and IT systems changes.
What a KAM description contains
Each KAM is described in a subsection with its own heading and a reference to related disclosures in the financial statements. The description explains why the matter was considered one of most significance and how it was addressed, which may include the auditor's approach, a summary of procedures and, sometimes, key observations. A KAM is not a substitute for a modified opinion, nor for disclosures that management is required to make. Matters giving rise to a qualified or adverse opinion, and a material uncertainty about going concern, are reported in their own sections instead; an emphasis of matter paragraph is not used for a matter already reported as a KAM. In rare cases the auditor may decide not to communicate a matter, for example where law prohibits public disclosure or where adverse consequences would clearly outweigh the public interest benefit.
Critical audit matters in the United States
The PCAOB adopted its new auditor reporting standard, AS 3101, in 2017, and the SEC approved it. CAM requirements took effect for audits of large accelerated filers for fiscal years ending on or after 30 June 2019, and for most other issuers for fiscal years ending on or after 15 December 2020. A CAM is a matter communicated or required to be communicated to the audit committee that relates to accounts or disclosures material to the financial statements and involved especially challenging, subjective or complex auditor judgement. The definition is narrower in some respects than ISA 701, since a CAM must relate to a material account or disclosure. Audits of emerging growth companies, brokers and dealers, most registered investment companies and employee benefit plans are exempt from the CAM requirement.
Assessment and criticism
Supporters say KAMs make auditor reports more informative, encourage better company disclosure and focus audit committee discussions. Studies and regulator reviews have found that most reports contain a small number of KAMs, often two to four, concentrated in a few predictable areas. Critics argue that the descriptions have become standardised, repeating similar wording each year and offering limited new information to investors. Some also note that the requirement may increase liability concerns for auditors, which can push towards cautious drafting. The effect on audited financial statements themselves is indirect, through the dialogue that KAMs prompt between auditors and management.