A substantive analytical procedure is an audit test that obtains evidence about an account balance or class of transactions by comparing the recorded amount with an expectation the auditor has developed independently. ISA 520 covers analytical procedures under international standards, and the PCAOB has a standard on substantive analytical procedures. They are used alongside, or instead of, tests of details.
The procedure has four steps: develop an expectation, for example payroll cost from headcount and average pay, or interest income from average balances and rates; set a threshold for acceptable differences, usually tied to performance materiality; compare the expectation with the recorded figure; and investigate any difference above the threshold. The method works best where relationships are stable and predictable, the data is reliable. It is less suitable for high-risk areas such as revenue recognition where fraud is a concern, where tests of detail are normally also needed. Simple ratio and variance reviews are a weaker form.