Pari passu is a Latin phrase meaning "with equal step", used in finance and law to describe obligations that rank equally with one another. Debts that rank pari passu have the same claim on the debtor's assets and payments: none is senior to the others, and if there is not enough to pay everyone in full, they share in proportion to the amounts owed. The term appears in loan agreements, bond documents, share issues and insolvency law, and it is a standard clause in international sovereign and corporate debt.
Pari passu is a statement about debt seniority. It contrasts with subordinated debt, which ranks behind other claims, and with senior secured debt, which has first call on particular assets. A pari passu undertaking is often paired with a negative pledge clause, which restricts the borrower from granting security to other creditors.
Pari passu clauses in loans and bonds
A typical clause states that the borrower's obligations under the agreement rank at least pari passu with all its other present and future unsecured and unsubordinated obligations, except those preferred by law. The aim is to stop the borrower from creating a class of unsecured debt that ranks ahead of the lender, for example by contract or by legislation favouring particular creditors. Mandatory preferences, such as certain tax or employee claims in insolvency, are carved out because a contract cannot override them.
In corporate lending the clause mainly matters in insolvency, where ranking is set by law. A secured creditor is paid from its collateral first, then preferred creditors, then unsecured creditors who rank pari passu and share what remains. The clause reinforces that the lender will not be pushed down the queue among unsecured creditors.
In loan syndication, pari passu also describes the relationship among the lenders. All lenders in a syndicate share payments and recoveries rateably, and a pro rata sharing clause requires any lender that receives more than its share, for example through set-off, to pass the excess to the agent for distribution. Changes to ranking or sharing usually require the consent of every lender, as they belong to the so-called sacred rights.
For shares, pari passu means that newly issued shares rank equally with existing shares of the same class for dividends and other rights.
Sovereign debt and the meaning of the clause
A sovereign borrower cannot be put into insolvency, so the pari passu clause in sovereign debt has long been debated. One reading, the ranking interpretation, holds that it only prevents the state from legally subordinating one class of creditors to another. A broader reading, the payment interpretation, holds that the state must also pay creditors in the class rateably and cannot pay some while refusing to pay others.
The payment reading gained attention in 2000, when a Brussels court granted Elliott Associates an order affecting payments by Peru on restructured debt. It became central in the litigation between NML Capital, an Elliott affiliate, and Argentina, which had defaulted in 2001 and restructured most of its bonds in exchanges in 2005 and 2010. Holders who declined the exchanges, often called holdouts, sued in New York.
NML Capital v Argentina
In December 2011 the federal district court in New York held that Argentina had breached the pari passu clause in its bonds by paying holders of the restructured bonds while passing a law barring payment to holdouts. In February 2012 the court issued an injunction requiring that, whenever Argentina paid the restructured bondholders, it also make a rateable payment to the plaintiffs. The Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit upheld the ruling, and in June 2014 the US Supreme Court declined to hear Argentina's appeal. Because payment agents and banks were barred from helping Argentina pay the restructured bonds without paying the holdouts, Argentina missed a coupon in July 2014 and was treated as in default again. A settlement with most holdouts was reached in 2016 under a new government.
The case alarmed sovereign borrowers and official lenders, because it gave holdouts a powerful tool against sovereign debt restructuring. In response, the International Capital Market Association published model terms in 2014 with a revised pari passu clause that expressly excludes any duty of rateable payment, alongside an aggregated collective action clause that lets a qualified majority of holders across several bond series bind the minority. Many new sovereign bonds governed by New York and English law have since adopted these terms.
Pari passu in insolvency and recovery
In insolvency the general rule of many legal systems, sometimes called the pari passu principle of distribution, is that unsecured creditors of the same rank share the available assets rateably. Departures from it, such as payments to favoured creditors shortly before insolvency, may be reversed as preferences. Because unsecured creditors share pro rata, unsecured creditor recovery depends on the size of the estate after secured and preferential claims are met.
Limitations
A pari passu clause does not give security, does not rank a lender ahead of secured creditors, and cannot override preferences created by statute. Its value depends on the other terms of the debt, especially the negative pledge and any intercreditor arrangements, and on the governing law, which decides how far courts will enforce it against a sovereign or a company in distress.
External links
Ref 1180001656