Operating lease classification is the conclusion that a lease does not transfer substantially all of the risks and rewards of owning the underlying asset to the lessee. The lessor keeps the asset on its balance sheet, depreciates it and earns rent, while the lessee pays for the use of the asset over a period shorter than its useful life or for less than its full value. Typical examples are office and retail leases, short vehicle hires and many aircraft leases.
An operating lease is defined by exclusion: it is any lease that fails the tests set out in finance lease classification. Since the arrival of IFRS 16 and the US standard ASC 842, the label matters in different ways for different parties. Under IFRS it applies only to lessors. Under US GAAP it applies to both lessees and lessors.
Background
Under the older standards, IAS 17 and ASC 840, an operating lease kept the lessee's obligation off the balance sheet, with rent simply expensed and future commitments disclosed in notes. Analysts routinely adjusted accounts to capitalise these commitments, and standard setters regarded the model as a form of off-balance-sheet financing. The IASB and the FASB ran a joint project to bring leases onto lessees' balance sheets, but reached different conclusions on how lessee leases should be expensed, which is why the operating category survives for US lessees and not for IFRS lessees.
Operating leases for lessors
Under both frameworks a lessor classifies a lease as operating when none of the finance indicators is met. The lessor continues to recognise the underlying asset and depreciates it under its normal policy, for example with the straight-line method. Lease income is recognised on a straight-line basis over the lease term unless another systematic basis better reflects the pattern of benefit. Initial direct costs are added to the carrying amount of the asset and expensed over the lease term, and the cost of lease incentives reduces income over the term. Under ASC 842 a lessor's lease is operating if it is neither sales-type nor direct financing.
Operating leases for lessees under ASC 842
A US GAAP lessee with an operating lease still recognises a right-of-use asset and a lease liability at commencement, measured in the same way as for a finance lease. The difference lies in the income statement and cash flows:
| Feature | Operating lease (ASC 842) | Finance lease (ASC 842) |
|---|---|---|
| Expense pattern | Single lease cost, generally straight-line | Amortisation plus interest, front-loaded |
| Income statement line | Within operating expenses | Amortisation in operating costs, interest in finance costs |
| Cash flow statement | Operating activities | Principal in financing, interest per policy |
| Asset reduction | Balancing figure that keeps total cost straight-line | Amortised separately, often straight-line |
The straight-line cost means an operating lease under ASC 842 looks in the income statement much as rent did under the old standard, which was a deliberate choice by the FASB. Under IFRS 16 there is no such choice. All lessee leases, apart from exempt ones, are treated in the finance-lease way, with depreciation and interest recognised separately. As a result, the same lease can raise reported EBITDA for an IFRS reporter but not for a US GAAP reporter, which complicates comparisons.
Exemptions and practical matters
Both frameworks allow lessees to keep short-term leases, those of 12 months or less without a purchase option the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise, off the balance sheet and expense the payments. IFRS 16 also offers an exemption for leases of low-value assets, such as laptops and small office furniture, which ASC 842 does not have.
Classification affects credit analysis and contracts. Lenders often define debt and EBITDA in a financial covenant with reference to a frozen set of accounting rules, partly to stop changes in lease accounting from moving covenant ratios. Classification is also central to sale-and-leaseback transactions, where a seller-lessee's ability to treat the transfer as a sale depends on the leaseback not being a finance lease under US GAAP. Lessors in sectors such as aircraft, rail and shipping leasing rely on operating leases as their core business model, earning rent over several leases of the same asset and taking the risk of its value at the end, so their results depend heavily on depreciation policy and residual value estimates. Banks and leasing companies that write mostly finance leases, by contrast, report interest-like income on a net investment. Judgments behind each classification, such as the expected economic life of the asset and the likelihood of option exercise, should be documented and are reviewed by auditors.