Exercise, in options trading, is the act by which the holder of an option invokes the right that the contract gives. The holder of a call option who exercises buys the underlying asset at the strike price. The holder of a put option who exercises sells it at the strike price. Exercise is a choice belonging to the holder alone. The writer of the option has no say and must perform if called upon.
Exercise is one of three ways an option position can end, the others being sale in the market before expiry and expiry without value. Most listed options are in fact closed by sale. The counterpart of exercise on the writer's side is assignment, the notice that a writer must deliver or buy the underlying. The same word is used for share warrants, as in warrant exercise, and for employee share options.
When an option can be exercised
The contract's exercise style fixes the permitted dates. An American option can be exercised on any business day up to and including expiration. A European option can be exercised only at expiration. Listed options on individual shares in the United States are American-style, and most options on broad indices are European-style.
Exercise makes sense only when the option is in the money, meaning the strike price is better than the market price. The amount gained by exercising, before the premium originally paid, is:
- is the current price of the underlying asset.
- is the strike price.
This is the option's intrinsic value. Exercising an option that is out of the money would mean buying above the market or selling below it, so it is not done.
The exercise process
For a listed option, the holder instructs the broker, and the broker passes an exercise notice to the clearing house, which in the United States is the Options Clearing Corporation. The clearing house assigns the notice at random to a member firm with a matching short position, and that firm allocates it to one of its customers by a fair method. The holder's exercise is irrevocable once submitted. Brokers set a cut-off time each day for instructions.
Settlement follows the contract terms. With physical settlement, used for an equity option, shares change hands against payment of the strike price: 100 shares per contract in the United States, settling on the next business day. With cash settlement, used for an index option, the writer pays the holder the exercise value in money and nothing is delivered.
At expiration the process is largely automatic. Under the clearing house's procedure, known as exercise by exception, options that are in the money by a small minimum amount are exercised without any instruction unless the holder says otherwise.
Exercise or sell
Before expiration, an option is normally worth more than its exercise value, because its price includes time value. Exercising throws that part away, so a holder who wants to realize a gain usually does better by selling the option.
Suppose a trader holds a call with a strike of $50 on a share trading at $56, and the option is quoted at $6.40. Exercising yields dollars a share. Selling the option yields $6.40. The difference of $0.40 a share, or $40 on a contract of 100 shares, is the time value that exercise would forfeit. Exercise would also require paying $5,000 for the shares.
Early exercise is rational in a few situations. The holder of a call may exercise just before the ex-dividend date to collect a dividend that is larger than the remaining time value. The holder of a deeply in-the-money put may exercise early to receive the strike price sooner and earn interest on it. Options with almost no time value left may be exercised when the market for them is too thin to sell at a fair price.
Risks at expiration
Automatic exercise can leave a holder with an unintended position. A call that finishes slightly in the money becomes a purchase of shares that must be paid for, and a put becomes a sale that may create a short position. If the account lacks the funds or the shares, the broker may close the option before expiry or liquidate the resulting position, and the holder bears any loss from price moves in between.
Writers face the mirror image. When the underlying closes very near the strike at the expiration date, the writer cannot know until the next day whether assignment has occurred, a problem known as pin risk. Holders may also exercise options that closed out of the money, or decline to exercise options that closed in the money, in response to news released after the close, since instructions can be given for a short time afterwards. Traders with positions near the strike therefore often close them before the final session ends.
Costs and tax
Exercise may carry a broker fee and requires the capital to pay for or deliver the underlying. Tax treatment differs by country and by type of option. In general, exercising a listed call is not itself treated as a disposal. The premium paid is added to the purchase cost of the shares, and tax arises when the shares are later sold. The rules for employee share options are different and often tax the gain at exercise.