A sale-and-leaseback transaction is an arrangement in which the owner of an asset sells it to a buyer, usually an investor or lessor, and at the same time leases it back for an agreed term. The seller becomes the lessee and keeps using the asset, while turning the value tied up in it into cash. The buyer gains an income-producing asset with a known tenant. The arrangement is also called a sale-leaseback or leaseback.
Sale-and-leasebacks are common in commercial property, aviation, shipping and equipment finance. They are a form of corporate financing as much as a property or asset deal, and they compete with secured borrowing such as a mortgage. Their accounting is governed by IFRS 16 for companies reporting under IFRS and by ASC 842 in the United States, both of which test whether a genuine sale has taken place.
Uses
- Real estate. Retailers, supermarket groups, hotel operators, manufacturers and banks sell head offices, stores or plants to investors such as real estate investment trusts on long net leases, where the tenant pays rent and most property costs.
- Aircraft. Airlines often sell newly delivered aircraft to operating lessors and lease them back, freeing capital and passing residual value risk to the lessor.
- Equipment and vehicles. Companies refinance machinery, rolling stock or fleets through leasing companies.
- Acquisition and restructuring finance. Private equity buyers and companies under financial pressure use leasebacks of owned property to raise funds, sometimes as part of a leveraged buyout.
Accounting under IFRS 16
IFRS 16 first asks whether the transfer satisfies the requirements for a sale under IFRS 15, essentially whether control of the asset has passed to the buyer. If it has, the seller-lessee derecognises the asset and recognises a right-of-use asset measured at the proportion of the asset's previous carrying amount that relates to the right of use retained. It recognises a gain or loss only on the rights actually transferred to the buyer. If the transfer is not a sale, the seller keeps the asset on its balance sheet and accounts for the cash received as a financial liability. An amendment issued in 2022 added requirements on how the seller-lessee measures the lease liability afterwards, so that it does not recognise a gain relating to the right of use it keeps.
The retained right of use is measured as:
Here PV is the present value of the leaseback payments, and the fair value is assumed to equal the sale price. Suppose a building with a carrying amount of 60 million is sold at its fair value of 100 million, and the present value of the leaseback payments is 45 million. The right-of-use asset is million. The total gain is million, of which the portion relating to rights transferred is million. The entries balance: cash 100 plus right-of-use asset 27 equals 127, matching the building derecognised at 60, the lease liability of 45 and the gain of 22.
Accounting under ASC 842
US GAAP also requires the transfer to qualify as a sale, here under ASC 606. Two features prevent sale accounting: a leaseback classified by the seller as a finance lease, and a repurchase option, unless the option is exercisable only at fair value and substantially similar assets are readily available in the market. When the sale succeeds, the seller-lessee recognises the full gain, adjusted for any off-market terms, and accounts for the leaseback as a new lease. When it fails, the transaction is treated as a financing: the seller continues to recognise and depreciate the asset and records the proceeds as a liability, while the buyer records a receivable. Because ASC 842 recognises the gain in full where IFRS 16 restricts it, the same deal can produce different results under the two frameworks.
Benefits and risks
For the seller, a leaseback can raise more money than a secured loan against the same asset, does not add financial covenants of the kind found in credit agreements, and lets management concentrate capital on the core business. For the buyer, it offers long-dated, often inflation-linked income from a tenant whose credit can be assessed.
The costs are a loss of ownership, of any rise in the asset's value and of flexibility to move or redevelop. Rent escalations can become burdensome, and lease obligations remain fixed claims in a downturn. Since IFRS 16 and ASC 842 brought most leases onto the balance sheet, leasebacks no longer serve as off-balance-sheet financing for lessees in the way older operating leases did, and credit rating agencies treat lease liabilities as debt-like. Several retail failures in which owned stores had earlier been sold and leased back have drawn criticism that such deals can transfer value from a company and its creditors to buyers and shareholders.