Negotiation, in the context of a documentary letter of credit, is the purchase by a nominated bank of drafts or documents presented under the credit, made by paying or agreeing to pay the beneficiary before the bank itself is reimbursed. It is one of the four ways a credit can be made available, alongside sight payment, deferred payment and acceptance. In practice it lets an exporter receive money soon after shipment, often at a discount, rather than waiting for the issuing bank to pay.
The term has a precise meaning under the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600), the ICC rules that govern most commercial credits. It should not be confused with the everyday sense of bargaining over contract terms, nor with the wider idea of negotiating a negotiable instrument by endorsement and delivery, although the two are historically related.
The UCP 600 definition
Article 2 of UCP 600 defines negotiation as the purchase by the nominated bank of drafts drawn on a bank other than the nominated bank, or of documents, or both, under a complying presentation, by advancing or agreeing to advance funds to the beneficiary on or before the banking day on which reimbursement is due to the nominated bank. Three elements matter. The presentation must comply with the credit; the bank must buy the documents or drafts, not merely handle them; and the funds must be advanced, or committed, no later than the day reimbursement falls due.
The rules also make clear that a nominated bank which only receives, examines and forwards documents, without purchasing them, has not negotiated and has not taken on any obligation to pay. This was a deliberate clarification. Under the earlier UCP 500, negotiation was described as "giving value", and disputes arose over whether a bank that had examined documents but not yet paid had negotiated. The UCP 600 wording, which allows an agreement to advance funds, also accommodates negotiation of deferred-payment presentations.
How negotiation works
A credit available by negotiation names the bank or banks with which it is available, or states that it is available with any bank, in which case it is a freely negotiable credit. After shipping, the beneficiary presents the documents and any draft to the negotiating bank. That bank checks them against the credit, following the international standard banking practice set out in ISBP 821. If they comply, it pays the beneficiary the face amount less interest for the expected period until reimbursement and its charges, then sends the documents to the issuing bank or claims from a reimbursing bank.
The amount advanced is effectively a discount of the future payment. The longer the expected time to reimbursement and the weaker the issuing bank or its country, the larger the deduction. If the documents contain a discrepancy, the bank may decline to negotiate, negotiate under reserve or against an indemnity, or send the documents on a collection basis for the applicant's approval.
Recourse and confirmation
Whether the negotiating bank can recover money from the beneficiary if the issuing bank fails to pay depends on its role. A nominated bank that has not confirmed the credit normally negotiates with recourse: under its agreement with the beneficiary, and in many legal systems, it can reclaim the advance if reimbursement never arrives. Its protection then rests on the issuing bank's undertaking, since UCP 600 obliges the issuing bank to reimburse a nominated bank that has honoured or negotiated a complying presentation.
A confirming bank is in a different position. By adding its confirmation it undertakes to negotiate without recourse when the credit is available by negotiation with it, so the beneficiary keeps the money even if the issuing bank defaults. This is the main reason exporters dealing with less familiar banks or higher-risk countries ask for a confirmed letter of credit.
Comparison with other forms of availability
- Sight payment. The nominated bank pays on presentation, as in a sight letter of credit, and there is no discount for waiting.
- Deferred payment. The bank undertakes to pay at a future date without a draft; under a deferred payment credit early funding is a separate prepayment or discount.
- Acceptance. The bank accepts a draft drawn on itself and pays at maturity, which creates an instrument such as a banker’s acceptance (BA) that can be discounted.
- Negotiation. The bank buys drafts drawn on another bank, or the documents, and provides funds before it is reimbursed.
Because negotiation combines document checking with financing, its pricing reflects both the credit risk on the issuing bank and the time value of money. Banks treat the resulting claim as a short-term exposure on that bank and its country, and it counts against their limits for that counterparty.
External links
Ref 1310000496