A confirmed letter of credit is a letter of credit to which a second bank, the confirming bank, adds its own definite undertaking to pay, accept a draft or negotiate when the beneficiary presents documents that comply with the credit's terms. The exporter then holds two independent promises: one from the issuing bank, which acts for the importer, and one from the confirming bank, which is usually a well-known bank in the exporter's own country or in a major financial centre.
Confirmation exists because a letter of credit is only as good as the bank that issues it and the country it sits in. An exporter selling to a buyer whose bank is small, poorly rated or located in a country with foreign-exchange shortages may doubt that the credit will actually be paid. Under the ICC's Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600), a confirmed credit shifts that doubt to a bank the exporter knows and can sue at home. The arrangement is closely related to documentary credit confirmation, the act by which the second bank takes on the obligation.
How confirmation works
The importer asks its bank for a confirmed credit, usually because the sale contract requires one. The issuing bank sends the credit to a bank in the exporter's country and requests or authorises it to add its confirmation. In a credit issued by SWIFT on an MT700, the confirmation instructions field shows whether the bank is asked to confirm, may add its confirmation, or is not to confirm. The bank that receives the credit often acts as the advising bank as well, but it only becomes a confirming bank once it agrees to add its undertaking.
When the beneficiary presents the documents, the confirming bank examines them against the credit, UCP 600 and international standard banking practice. If the presentation is a complying presentation, the confirming bank must pay or negotiate even if the issuing bank later fails, becomes subject to sanctions or is prevented by its government from transferring funds. The confirming bank then claims reimbursement from the issuing bank. If the documents contain discrepancies, the confirming bank is not bound, and the case moves into discrepancy handling.
The confirming bank's undertaking under UCP 600
UCP 600 defines confirmation as a definite undertaking of the confirming bank, in addition to that of the issuing bank, to honour or negotiate a complying presentation. Article 8 sets out the confirming bank's obligations: it must honour or negotiate a complying presentation made to it, it is irrevocably bound from the moment it adds its confirmation, and it must reimburse any other nominated bank that has honoured or negotiated; the issuing bank's duty to reimburse is set out in Article 7. A bank that is asked to confirm but is not willing to do so must tell the issuing bank without delay, and it may still advise the credit without confirmation.
Because confirmation is an additional promise rather than a guarantee of the issuing bank, the beneficiary may present documents directly to the confirming bank and be paid by it. The confirming bank cannot later recover the money from the beneficiary on the ground that the issuing bank did not pay, which is what distinguishes it from negotiation with recourse. Confirmation only makes sense for an irrevocable letter of credit, and all credits under UCP 600 are irrevocable.
Why exporters ask for confirmation
The main risks that confirmation removes from the exporter are:
- Issuing bank risk. The issuing bank may be unknown to the exporter, weakly capitalised or unwilling to pay promptly, which is a form of counterparty risk.
- Country and transfer risk. Even a sound issuing bank may be unable to pay if its government restricts payments abroad, a problem described as transfer risk and, more broadly, country risk.
- Political events. War, sanctions or a moratorium on external debt can stop payment regardless of the importer's wishes, a type of political risk.
A confirmation also lets the exporter be paid locally, under familiar law, and borrow against a claim on a strong bank.
Pricing and confirmation fees
The confirming bank charges a confirmation fee that reflects its view of the issuing bank and the country. The fee is usually quoted as a percentage of the credit amount for each period the confirmation is outstanding, often per quarter or per annum, with a minimum charge. A simple calculation is:
Here is the credit amount, is the annual confirmation rate written as a decimal, and is the number of days the confirmation runs. For a credit of 1,000,000 US dollars confirmed at 1.2 per cent a year for 90 days, the fee is dollars. The credit states which party bears the fee, and a bank with no spare limit for the issuing bank or country may decline to confirm at all.
Silent confirmation and alternatives
Sometimes the issuing bank does not ask for confirmation, or forbids it, but the exporter still wants protection. A bank may then offer a silent confirmation, a private agreement with the beneficiary to pay against complying documents. A silent confirmation is not a confirmation under UCP 600, because the issuing bank never authorised it, so the bank's position depends on its contract with the beneficiary and on taking an assignment of the proceeds.
Export credit insurance and risk participations sold to other banks can cover similar risks, but only a confirmation gives the beneficiary a direct claim on a second bank from the moment the credit is advised.
External links
Ref 1310000372