A commodity trading advisor (CTA) is an individual or firm that, for compensation or profit, advises others about the value or advisability of trading futures contracts, options on futures, swaps or certain foreign exchange contracts. The definition comes from the Commodity Exchange Act. It covers both those who give advice directly and those who exercise trading authority over client accounts.
In the United States such advisers must register with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and join the National Futures Association unless exempt. In the investment industry the abbreviation has a second, looser meaning: it is used for managers of managed futures strategies in general, wherever they are based and however they are regulated. The adviser is the futures-market counterpart of the investment adviser in securities markets.
How advisers operate
An adviser reaches clients in two main ways. In a managed account, the client opens an account in the client's own name at a futures commission merchant and signs a power of attorney that lets the adviser place trades. The client sees every position and can close the account at any time. Alternatively the adviser trades the assets of a commodity pool, in which many investors' money is combined. The pool is run by a commodity pool operator, which may be the same firm.
Advisers generally do not hold client money. Funds stay with the clearing firm, and the adviser has authority only to trade. Compensation is typically a management fee on assets plus a performance fee on new profits.
Regulation
Registration involves fitness checks on the firm's principals and individual registration of staff who deal with clients, each as an associated person. A registered adviser must give prospective clients a disclosure document setting out the trading programme, the risks, fees, conflicts of interest and past performance calculated in a prescribed way. It must keep records and is subject to examination.
Exemptions exist for advisers with a small number of clients who do not hold themselves out to the public, for those whose advice is incidental to another business such as banking, publishing or farming, and for firms already registered in another capacity. Advisers dealing only with sophisticated clients are relieved of much of the disclosure detail. The anti-fraud rules apply to all, registered or not.
Strategies
Advisers are usually grouped by how decisions are made and what they are based on:
- Systematic trend following. The largest group uses computer models that buy markets that have been rising and sell those that have been falling, across dozens of futures on shares, bonds, currencies and commodities. Trend following is so dominant that the abbreviation is often used as a synonym for it.
- Other systematic approaches. These include short-term pattern recognition, relative-value trades between related markets and models based on economic data, all forms of quantitative trading.
- Discretionary. The manager decides on the basis of judgment about supply and demand, policy or market conditions. Specialists in agricultural or energy markets often work this way.
Most programmes can be long or short with equal ease and use the leverage built into futures, sizing each position so that the portfolio runs at a target level of risk.
Role in portfolios and performance
Investors allocate to managed futures mainly for diversification. Because trend followers can profit from falling as well as rising markets, their returns have had low correlation with shares over long periods. The strategy performed strongly in 2008, when equities fell sharply, and again in 2022, when shares and bonds declined together and trends in interest rates and commodities were persistent.
The record is uneven. During much of the decade after 2009, when markets were calmer and reversals frequent, industry returns were low and many investors withdrew. Trend following tends to produce many small losses and occasional large gains, with long periods below the previous peak, so measures such as maximum drawdown matter as much as the Sharpe ratio when programmes are compared. There is no assurance that gains will arrive during any particular equity decline, especially a sudden one that reverses before trends form.
Criticism and limitations
Fees have been the main criticism. Studies of publicly offered futures funds found that charges absorbed a large part of gross returns over long periods. Fee levels have since fallen, and low-cost funds that follow simple trend rules now compete with traditional advisers.
Performance data are another concern. Industry indices are built from results that advisers report voluntarily, so they can be flattered by the omission of failed programmes, a form of survivorship bias. Track records based on simulation, not actual trading, are subject to the weaknesses of backtesting, and regulators require them to be labelled as hypothetical. The similarity of many programmes also means that advisers can be forced to exit the same positions at once.