The money multiplier is the ratio of the broad money supply to the monetary base, the currency and bank reserves created by a central bank. In the textbook account it describes how a fractional-reserve banking system can turn one unit of new reserves into several units of deposits, because banks keep only part of each deposit as reserves and lend out the rest, and the money they lend is deposited again elsewhere in the system.
The concept is a standard part of introductory economics and was long used to explain how central banks control the quantity of money. Its practical value has become much more limited. The measured multiplier varies widely over time, many central banks set interest rates rather than targeting the base, and in the United States the reserve requirement that the simple formula relies on was cut to zero in March 2020. The idea is distinct from the fiscal multiplier, which concerns the effect of government spending on output.
The simple deposit multiplier
Suppose a central bank buys a bond from a bank for $1,000, adding $1,000 to the bank's reserves, and the bank is required to hold 10 per cent of deposits as reserves. The bank lends out the $900 it does not need to keep. The borrower spends it, and the recipient deposits it in another bank, which keeps $90 and lends $810. The process continues in ever smaller rounds, and total deposits approach $10,000. The general formula is:
where is the simple deposit multiplier and is the required reserve ratio, written as a decimal. With , the multiplier is , and $1,000 of new reserves supports dollars of deposits. The same total follows from adding the rounds: .
A fuller version with currency and excess reserves
The simple formula assumes that people hold no cash and that banks lend out every unit above the required minimum. In practice the public keeps some currency outside banks, and banks may hold excess reserves. A widely used extension relates the money supply , made up of currency and deposits, to the base :
- is the ratio of currency held by the public to deposits.
- is the required reserve ratio.
- is the ratio of excess reserves to deposits.
With , and , the multiplier is , far below the simple value of 10. Every leak of money out of the lending chain, into cash or idle reserves, shrinks the multiplier. Because and depend on the choices of households and banks, the multiplier is not a fixed number and can change quickly.
Why the multiplier proved unstable
The fuller formula explains why the measured ratio of money to the base has moved so much. In a crisis, households may hoard cash and banks may hold large precautionary reserves, both of which reduce the multiplier. After 2008, when the Federal Reserve and other central banks expanded their balance sheets through quantitative easing, the monetary base grew many times over but broad money grew far less, so the multiplier fell sharply. A large increase in reserves did not lead to a proportional surge in lending.
Many central banks and economists now describe the causation as running mostly the other way. In a widely cited 2014 article, the Bank of England explained that commercial banks create deposits when they make loans, limited mainly by profitable lending opportunities, capital rules and the price of credit, and that the central bank then supplies the reserves the system needs at its chosen interest rate. On this view the quantity of money is determined largely by the demand for credit, and the multiplier is an outcome rather than a lever.
The multiplier under ample reserves
The Federal Reserve now operates an ample-reserves framework, under which the banking system holds enough bank reserves that small changes in their quantity do not move short-term interest rates. The FOMC confirmed in January 2019 that it intended to keep operating this way. Policy is implemented mainly by setting administered rates such as interest on reserves, rather than by adjusting reserves through open market operations so as to hit a quantity target.
In March 2020 the Federal Reserve reduced reserve requirement ratios to zero, so no US bank is now required to hold reserves against its deposits. In the simple formula this would imply an infinite multiplier, which shows that the textbook model no longer describes the US system. The multiplier remains useful as a teaching device and as a description of the arithmetic linking reserves, cash and deposits, and the ratio of money to the base is still reported as a statistic, but it is not regarded as a reliable guide to how central bank actions affect the money supply.
External links
Ref 1100001712