Money creation is the process by which new money comes into existence in a modern economy. Most of the money held by households and firms takes the form of bank deposits, and these are created mainly by commercial banks when they make loans: a bank that lends credits the borrower's account with a new deposit, adding to the money supply. Central banks create the other forms of money, banknotes and the reserves that banks hold in accounts at the central bank.
This description, set out by the Bank of England in a widely cited 2014 article, differs from the traditional textbook story of the money multiplier, in which banks lend out deposits they already hold and the central bank controls the quantity of money through the amount of reserves. In practice central banks set the price of reserves, the policy interest rate, and the amount of lending is limited by banks' profitability, borrowers' demand, regulation and monetary policy rather than by a fixed reserve ratio.
How commercial banks create money
When a bank grants a loan of 10,000, it records two entries at once: a new asset, the loan owed by the borrower, and a new liability, the 10,000 deposit credited to the borrower's account. No existing deposit is used up, so the stock of broad money rises by 10,000. This deposit is commercial bank money, a promise by the bank to pay on demand. When the borrower spends it, the deposit moves to the seller's account, often at another bank, and the two banks settle the payment by transferring reserves between their accounts at the central bank.
The process also runs in reverse. When a borrower repays a loan, the deposit and the loan are cancelled together and money is destroyed. Banks also create deposits when they buy assets, such as bonds, from non-bank investors, and destroy them when they sell assets to non-banks or issue long-term bonds and shares that investors pay for out of their deposits. The money supply at any time is the net result of these flows across the whole banking system.
Central bank money
Central banks create two kinds of money: banknotes, which make up currency in circulation, and bank reserves, the balances that commercial banks hold at the central bank. Together these form the monetary base, also called central bank money. The central bank creates reserves when it lends to banks or buys assets from them, and withdraws them when loans are repaid or assets sold. Banknotes enter circulation when banks draw them from the central bank to meet customer demand, paying with reserves.
Reserves can only be held by banks and similar institutions with central bank accounts, so they are not lent out to households. Under quantitative easing, a central bank that buys a government bond from a pension fund creates new reserves for the fund's bank and, at the same time, a new deposit for the fund, so both central bank money and broad money rise.
The money multiplier and its limits
The textbook model treats broad money as a fixed multiple of the monetary base:
- is broad money and the monetary base.
- is the public's ratio of cash to deposits.
- is the ratio of reserves that banks hold to deposits.
With and , the multiplier is , so a base of 100 would support broad money of 550. The model assumes that the central bank fixes the quantity of reserves and that banks lend until they reach a required ratio. In practice most central banks target an interest rate and supply whatever reserves are needed at that rate, and many have no binding reserve requirement: the Bank of England has none for monetary purposes, and the Federal Reserve cut its reserve requirement ratios to zero in March 2020. The multiplier is therefore better seen as an outcome of bank and customer behaviour than as a mechanism. After large-scale asset purchases from 2008 onward, the monetary base grew far faster than broad money in the United States, the UK and the euro area, which the fixed-multiplier story cannot explain.
What limits money creation
Banks cannot create money without limit. Their lending is constrained by several forces:
- Profitability and competition. A bank lends only when the interest it can earn exceeds its funding costs and expected losses, and it competes with other banks for both borrowers and deposits.
- Demand for credit. Households and firms must want to borrow, and they can destroy money by repaying debt.
- Regulation. Capital requirements and liquidity rules under Basel III tie lending to the bank's equity and liquid assets.
- Monetary policy. The policy rate, including the interest paid on reserves, sets the cost of funding and so the price of loans throughout the economy.
Through these channels the central bank influences money creation indirectly, by raising or lowering the cost of credit, rather than by rationing reserves. Debates continue over how far rapid money growth causes inflation and over proposals that would separate deposit-taking from lending.
External links
Ref 1100001816