Marginal private and social costs and benefits are the building blocks economists use to analyse an externality, a cost or benefit that falls on people outside a transaction. Private measures count only what the buyer or seller pays or gains. Social measures add the effects on everyone else, such as neighbours breathing polluted air or the wider public protected when someone is vaccinated. When the two differ, a free market produces the wrong amount of a good, a classic case of market failure.
The idea goes back to the British economist Arthur Pigou, whose 1920 book The Economics of Welfare distinguished private from social net product. The relations are simple: marginal social cost is marginal private cost plus marginal external cost, and marginal social benefit is marginal private benefit plus marginal external benefit. The efficient output is where marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost. Each concept is covered below, ending with a worked example of the socially optimal quantity.
Marginal Private Cost
Marginal private cost (MPC) is the extra cost to a producer of making one more unit of a good: the additional labor, materials, energy and other inputs the firm itself pays for. It is the ordinary marginal cost of a firm's accounts, and the market supply curve is built from it, because each firm decides how much to supply by comparing price with its own costs. Marginal private cost leaves out any cost the firm does not pay. A power station counts its fuel and staff but not the damage its smoke does to the health of people downwind. When such third-party costs exist, marginal private cost is below the true cost to society, so the market supply curve sits too low and too far to the right, and the market produces more than is socially efficient. When no externality exists, marginal private cost and marginal social cost are the same.
Marginal External Cost (MEC)
Marginal external cost (MEC), also called additional external cost, is the extra cost imposed on third parties when one more unit of a good is produced or consumed. Examples include the health and crop damage from each extra tonne of sulphur dioxide, the congestion one more car adds to a busy road, or the noise from an extra flight. It is the per-unit measure of a negative externality. Marginal external cost links the private and social measures:
where MSC is marginal social cost and MPC marginal private cost. If a factory's private cost of one more unit is $40 and the pollution from that unit does $15 of damage to others, the marginal social cost is dollars. Estimating MEC is the hard part in practice, since it requires valuing harms that are not traded in any market.
Marginal Social Cost
Marginal social cost (MSC) is the total cost to society of producing one more unit of a good: the producer's own marginal private cost plus the marginal external cost borne by everyone else. Drawn on a supply-and-demand diagram, the MSC curve lies above the market supply curve wherever there is a negative externality, and the vertical gap between them is the marginal external cost. The efficient level of output is where marginal social cost equals marginal social benefit, because up to that point each unit is worth more to society than it costs. A market that ignores the external part settles where private supply meets demand, producing too much. The units produced beyond the efficient level cost society more than they are worth, and the total of those net losses is the deadweight loss of the externality. Policies such as a Pigouvian tax aim to make producers face marginal social cost rather than marginal private cost.
Social cost is the total cost to society of an activity: the private cost paid by the producer or consumer plus all external costs falling on others. Where marginal social cost refers to one more unit, social cost refers to the whole amount produced. The gap between social cost and private cost shows the size of a negative externality. The best-known application is the social cost of carbon, an estimate of the money value of the damage caused by emitting one more tonne of carbon dioxide, which several governments have used in cost-benefit analysis of regulations. Estimates vary widely with assumptions about future damage and the discount rate, so they have been revised and disputed many times. Measuring social cost relies on the methods described under valuing environmental costs and benefits, such as surveys and studies of house prices near polluting sites.
Marginal Private Benefit
Marginal private benefit (MPB) is the extra benefit that the buyer of one more unit, or the person doing one more unit of an activity, receives personally. It is what that person is willing to pay for the unit, so the market demand curve reflects marginal private benefit, the same idea described under marginal benefit. For most goods, private and social benefits are the same. They differ when a good also helps others: a person who is vaccinated gains protection, but also lowers the chance of passing the disease to others; a student who stays in education gains higher earnings, but society may also gain from a more skilled workforce. In such cases of positive externality, buyers base their choices on marginal private benefit alone, which is below the benefit to society, so the market buys too little of the good.
Marginal Social Benefit
Marginal social benefit (MSB) is the total benefit to society of one more unit of a good: the marginal private benefit to the buyer plus any marginal external benefit to others:
where MEB is the marginal external benefit. If one more flu vaccination is worth $30 to the person vaccinated and reduces illness among others by a value of $20, its marginal social benefit is dollars. On a diagram the MSB curve lies above the market demand curve when there is a positive externality. Efficient output is where MSB equals marginal social cost. Because the market stops where private benefit equals cost, it under-provides such goods, which is the economic case for a subsidy, free provision or rules such as compulsory schooling, and part of the reasoning behind a merit good.
Social Benefit
Social benefit is the total benefit to society from an activity: the private benefit to those who buy or use it plus the external benefit to everyone else. It is the whole-quantity counterpart of marginal social benefit. A new metro line, for example, benefits its passengers, who pay fares, but also drivers who face less traffic, businesses near stations and people breathing cleaner air. Counting only fare revenue would understate its social benefit. Governments use social benefit, set against social cost, when appraising roads, health programmes and regulations, and when deciding whether a project worth doing for society needs public funding because private buyers will not pay for all of it. The term here means benefit in the economic sense; it is not the same as social security or welfare benefits, which are payments to households.
Socially Optimal Quantity
The socially optimal quantity is the level of output at which marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost, so that every unit worth more to society than it costs is produced and no other unit is. It differs from the market quantity whenever there are externalities: higher than the market quantity for goods with external benefits and lower for goods with external costs. Suppose demand, which equals both private and social benefit, is , marginal private cost is and pollution adds a constant marginal external cost of 10. The market sets , so and the price is 60. The social optimum sets , so and the price is 65. The deadweight loss of the extra five units is . A Pigouvian tax of 10 per unit moves the market to the optimum; emissions trading and other environmental policy instruments pursue the same aim, while the Coase theorem shows that bargaining can sometimes reach it without government.
Ref 1100001702
Social Cost