Loanable funds is an economic model in which the real interest rate is determined by the supply of saving available to be lent and the demand for borrowing. In the loanable funds market, savers, mainly households but also firms and governments running surpluses, supply funds, while borrowers, chiefly firms financing investment in capital and governments running deficits, demand them. The real interest rate, the nominal rate minus expected inflation, is the price that brings the two into balance.
The model is a staple of introductory macroeconomics and of classical economics more broadly. It is used to explain how saving finances investment, how government borrowing can push up interest rates, and how changes in thrift or business confidence affect the cost of credit. It is a simplified picture: in practice funds flow through banks, the bond market and other intermediaries, and central banks set short-term rates. It sits alongside, and is often contrasted with, the liquidity preference theory of John Maynard Keynes.
How the loanable funds market works
The supply curve of loanable funds slopes upwards: a higher real interest rate rewards saving, so households save and lend more. The demand curve slopes downwards: at a lower real interest rate more investment projects become profitable, so firms want to borrow more. The equilibrium real interest rate is where the two curves cross, and there the quantity of funds lent equals the quantity borrowed.
In a closed economy, the model rests on a national accounting identity. Output not consumed by households or bought by the government is national saving, and it equals investment:
- is national saving and is investment.
- is total output, which equals total income.
- is household consumption and is government purchases of goods and services.
If , and , national saving is , and in equilibrium investment is also 150. National saving combines private saving and public saving, which is the government's budget surplus (taxes minus spending). In an open economy, foreign saving adds to supply, so investment can exceed domestic saving when a country borrows from abroad.
What shifts supply and demand
- Thrift. If households decide to save more at every interest rate, for example because of an aging population or tax incentives for retirement saving, supply shifts right, the real interest rate falls and investment rises.
- The government budget. A larger budget deficit reduces public saving and so the supply of funds (some presentations show it as extra demand instead). Either way, the real interest rate rises.
- Investment opportunities. New technology or optimism about future profits shifts demand right, raising both the interest rate and the amount lent.
- Taxes. Taxes on interest income, or investment tax credits, change the after-tax rewards to saving and investing.
- Capital flows. In an open economy, inflows from abroad add to supply and outflows reduce it.
Crowding out
The model's best-known application is crowding out. When a government borrows more to finance a deficit, it competes with private borrowers for the same pool of saving. The real interest rate rises, and some private investment that would have been profitable at the old rate no longer goes ahead. The size of the effect depends on how strongly saving and investment respond to the interest rate: if saving rises sharply with rates, little investment is displaced. Crowding out is a central argument about the long-run cost of persistent deficits and a high national debt, because lower investment means a smaller capital stock and lower future output.
Critics note that crowding out is weakest when the economy has spare capacity. In a recession, idle savings and weak private demand for credit mean that government borrowing may raise income without pushing interest rates up much, which is the basis of arguments for a large fiscal multiplier in downturns.
Limits of the model and liquidity preference
The loanable funds model treats saving as a pool of money that banks pass on to borrowers. Critics, including economists at the Bank of England in a 2014 article on money creation, point out that banks create new deposits when they make loans, so lending is not limited by a prior stock of saving in the way the model suggests. It is limited instead by bank capital, regulation, the demand for credit and the central bank's policy rate. The model also says little about money, risk or the role of monetary policy.
Keynes's liquidity preference theory offers a different account, in which the interest rate is the reward for giving up liquidity and is set by the demand for and supply of money, while saving and investment are brought into line mainly by changes in income. Modern macroeconomics often combines the two: over long horizons the loanable funds framework helps explain the equilibrium real interest rate, while in the short run central bank policy and liquidity preference dominate. Frictions such as credit rationing, where lenders limit loans rather than raise rates, add further qualifications.
Ref 1100001697