Capital flows are movements of money between countries for the purpose of acquiring assets or extending credit. They include a company building a factory abroad, a pension fund buying foreign shares or government bonds, and a bank lending to a borrower in another country. They are distinct from payments for traded goods and services, though the two are linked: a country that imports more than it exports must finance the gap with capital from abroad.
The flows are recorded in the balance of payments. They matter most visibly for emerging markets, where inflows can finance investment and growth but can also reverse abruptly, with sharp effects on exchange rates, asset prices and the banking system. The subject is a central concern of the International Monetary Fund and of central banks.
Main types
- Foreign direct investment. Foreign direct investment is the acquisition of a lasting interest in a business, by building new operations or buying a significant stake, conventionally 10 percent or more of voting power. It is the most stable category.
- Portfolio investment. Purchases of shares and bonds without a controlling interest. These can be sold quickly and are sensitive to market sentiment.
- Other investment. Chiefly bank loans, deposits and trade credit. Cross-border bank lending has been the most volatile component in several crises.
- Reserve assets. Changes in the foreign exchange reserves held by the central bank, which absorb or supply foreign currency.
Short-term flows that move quickly in search of higher returns are informally called hot money. Statisticians also distinguish gross flows, the total purchases by foreigners and by residents separately, from net flows, the difference between them.
The accounting identity
Leaving aside measurement errors, the balance of payments must sum to zero. In simplified form:
- is the balance on the current account, covering trade in goods and services and income.
- is the balance on the capital account, a small item in most countries covering capital transfers.
- is the financial account balance, the net acquisition of foreign assets less the net incurrence of liabilities, including reserves.
Suppose a country has a current account deficit of 30 billion dollars and a capital account balance of zero. Its financial account balance must be billion: residents have taken on 30 billion more in liabilities to foreigners than they have acquired in foreign assets. If private investors supplied only 20 billion, the central bank must have sold 10 billion of reserves. A country cannot run a current account deficit without a matching net inflow of capital.
What drives the flows
Economists group the causes into push factors, arising in the investing countries, and pull factors, arising in the recipients. Push factors include low interest rates in the advanced economies, the stance of the Federal Reserve, the strength of the dollar and the appetite of global investors for risk. When rates in the United States are low and markets calm, investors seek higher yields elsewhere. A wide interest rate differential encourages the carry trade, in which money is borrowed in a low-rate currency and placed in a high-rate one.
Pull factors include a country's growth prospects, the soundness of its public finances and banks, the quality of its institutions and its openness to foreign investors. Research suggests that push factors explain much of the timing of surges and retreats across countries, while pull factors help to explain which countries receive more.
Benefits and risks
In principle, capital flowing from countries with abundant savings to countries with profitable investment opportunities benefits both. Recipients can invest more than they save, direct investment brings technology and management skills, and investors diversify their holdings.
The risks arise from volatility. Large inflows push up the exchange rate, which hurts exporters, and can fuel rapid credit growth and asset price bubbles. When sentiment changes, inflows can stop or reverse within weeks, an event known as a sudden stop. The currency falls, borrowers with debts in foreign currency find them heavier, and banks and governments may lose access to funding. In severe cases residents also move money out, which is capital flight.
The Latin American debt crisis of the 1980s, the Asian financial crisis of 1997 to 1998 and the market turbulence of 2013, when signals that the Federal Reserve would slow its bond purchases led to heavy selling of emerging market assets, all followed this pattern. Countries that borrow abroad in their own currency, hold ample reserves and have flexible exchange rates have generally proved more resilient.
Policy responses
Governments have several tools. They can let the currency adjust, intervene in the foreign exchange market using reserves, tighten or loosen monetary and fiscal policy, and apply prudential limits on banks' foreign currency borrowing. They can also restrict the flows directly with capital controls, such as taxes on inflows or limits on outflows.
Opinion on controls has shifted. From the 1980s many countries pursued capital account liberalization, and controls were widely regarded as harmful. After the crises of the 1990s and 2008, the International Monetary Fund adopted a formal position in 2012, revised in 2022, accepting that what it calls capital flow management measures can be appropriate in some circumstances, though not as a substitute for sound economic policy. The underlying constraint is that a country cannot have free capital movement, a fixed exchange rate and an independent monetary policy all at once.