A command economy, also called a centrally planned economy, is an economic system in which a central authority makes the main decisions about production, investment, prices and incomes. State planners set targets for what factories and farms must produce, allocate raw materials and labour among them, and fix the prices at which goods are sold. The means of production are largely owned by the state.
The system is the opposite of a market economy, in which those decisions emerge from the choices of households and firms responding to prices. No economy is purely one or the other. Most countries today are a mixed economy, with markets doing most of the allocation and the state intervening to varying degrees. The command model is associated above all with the Soviet Union and the states that followed its example in the twentieth century.
How planning works
In the classic Soviet form a state planning agency drew up a plan, typically for five years, with annual plans beneath it. The plan specified output targets for each industry in physical units, such as tonnes of steel or numbers of tractors. Ministries passed the targets down to individual enterprises, together with allocations of inputs. Managers were rewarded for meeting or exceeding the quantities set.
Prices existed but did not perform the role they have under capitalism. They were set administratively, often left unchanged for years, and served mainly for accounting. Because a price did not move to balance supply and demand, the planners had to balance each product directly, matching planned sources against planned uses across thousands of goods. Foreign trade and banking were state monopolies, and private enterprise was banned or confined to small niches.
History
The first full command economy was built in the Soviet Union after 1928, when the government launched the first five-year plan, forced farms into collectives and directed resources into heavy industry. The model was rooted in Marxism and in the belief that planning would be more rational and fairer than markets. After the Second World War it was adopted across Eastern Europe, in China, North Korea, Cuba and Vietnam, and in modified form in a number of newly independent states.
Market economies have also used command methods in wartime. During both world wars the governments of Britain, Germany and the United States rationed consumer goods, fixed prices and directed factories to produce arms.
From the 1970s growth in the planned economies slowed and the gap with the West widened. China began market reforms in 1978. The communist governments of Eastern Europe fell in 1989, the Soviet Union dissolved in 1991, and most of these countries moved to market systems through liberalization of prices and privatization of state firms. North Korea and Cuba are the main remaining examples, and both tolerate some private activity.
Claimed advantages
Supporters argued that planning could mobilize resources quickly for national goals. The Soviet Union industrialized within a generation and produced the armaments that helped defeat Germany. A command system can hold open unemployment close to zero, because enterprises are instructed to employ the available workers, and it can keep the prices of housing, food and transport low and stable. Income differences from wages were generally smaller than in market economies, and there was no income from private ownership of capital. These features came with heavy costs in efficiency and personal freedom.
Criticism
The central objection, raised by the economist Ludwig von Mises in 1920 and developed by Friedrich Hayek, is known as the economic calculation problem. Without market prices for capital goods, they argued, planners have no way to compare the costs of different methods of production and so cannot use resources rationally. Hayek added that the knowledge needed to run an economy is dispersed among millions of people and cannot be gathered by a central office. A market price summarizes that knowledge and passes it on. This coordinating role is the idea behind the invisible hand.
Experience brought out further weaknesses:
- Shortages. With prices held below the level that would clear the market, goods ran out and were allocated by queues, rationing and connections. The Hungarian economist Janos Kornai described the system as a shortage economy.
- Poor incentives. Targets set by quantity encouraged managers to neglect quality, hide capacity and hoard inputs. Loss-making enterprises were kept alive with subsidies, so there was little pressure to cut costs.
- Weak innovation. Without competition or the threat of failure, enterprises had little reason to adopt new products or methods.
- Informal markets. Scarcity produced widespread illegal trading, and prices in that trade were far above official ones.
- Concentration of power. Control of all economic resources by the state was closely tied to political repression.
Economists generally regard the record as evidence that comprehensive planning fails at allocative efficiency, the task of directing resources to the uses people value most.
A command economy is not the same as socialism in general, which includes market-based variants, or as communism, which in theory describes a stateless society. It also differs from state capitalism, in which the state owns or steers large firms that still operate in markets and respond to prices. Nationalization of particular industries within a market economy does not by itself create a command system.