Blue sky laws are the securities laws of the individual states of the United States. Each state has its own statute governing the offer and sale of securities to its residents, the licensing of the firms and individuals who sell them or give investment advice, and the punishment of fraud. They operate alongside federal law, which is administered by the Securities and Exchange Commission.
The laws are enforced by a securities regulator in each state, often a division of the state's department of commerce, financial regulation or the attorney general's office. An issuer selling securities across the country may therefore have to satisfy federal requirements and the requirements of every state in which it sells, unless an exemption or federal preemption applies.
Origins of the name and the laws
Kansas passed the first comprehensive statute of this kind in 1911, requiring both securities and their sellers to be approved by a state official before any sale. Other states followed within a few years. The name is usually traced to remarks of the period about promoters whose schemes had no more substance than so many feet of blue sky. The United States Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of such statutes in 1917.
State regulation thus came about two decades before the federal Securities Act of 1933 and Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Congress chose to keep the state systems in place when it passed those acts, creating the dual structure that still exists.
The Uniform Securities Act
Because fifty separate statutes made nationwide offerings burdensome, a model law, the Uniform Securities Act, was published in 1956 and revised in 1985 and 2002. Most states have adopted one of its versions, with local variations. State regulators cooperate through the North American Securities Administrators Association, which was founded in 1919 and also includes Canadian and Mexican regulators.
Registration of securities
Unless a security or a transaction is exempt, it must be registered in the state before it is offered there. State securities registration takes three traditional forms:
- Notification, or filing. A streamlined procedure for established issuers that meet set standards of size and earnings history. It is not available in every state.
- Coordination. The usual method for an offering that is also being registered with the SEC, such as an initial public offering. The issuer files the federal prospectus and related documents with the state, and state registration becomes effective at the same time as the federal one.
- Qualification. A full review by the state, used for offerings that are not registered federally, such as those sold only within one state.
Federal law is based on disclosure: an offering may proceed if investors are given full and accurate information. Many state laws go further and allow merit review, under which the regulator may refuse registration if it judges the terms unfair to investors, for instance because promoters' compensation is excessive.
Federal preemption
The National Securities Markets Improvement Act of 1996 sharply reduced the reach of state registration. It created a class of covered securities that states may not require to be registered or subject to merit review. The class includes securities listed on national exchanges such as the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq, shares of registered investment companies such as a mutual fund, and securities sold in certain exempt offerings, notably a private placement to an accredited investor under Rule 506 of Regulation D. States may still require a notice filing and a fee for some of these offerings.
Preemption does not remove the states' power to investigate and prosecute fraud, which applies to every securities transaction within their borders whether or not the security is covered.
Licensing of firms and individuals
Blue sky laws require a broker-dealer doing business in a state, and its sales agents, to register there. Applications and records are handled through the Central Registration Depository, a shared database, and agents normally must pass a state law examination in addition to federal qualification exams. Responsibility for an investment adviser is divided by size. Under the Dodd-Frank Act, advisers managing less than roughly $100 million are in general regulated by the states and larger ones by the SEC.
Enforcement and criticism
State regulators can issue cease-and-desist orders, deny or revoke licences, impose fines and refer cases for criminal prosecution. Many statutes give investors a right to cancel a purchase and recover their money if a security was sold unregistered or by means of a misstatement. State authorities have been prominent in cases involving unregistered investment contracts, including crypto lending products, where they apply the same definition of a security as the federal Howey test or a state variant.
Critics argue that complying with many state regimes adds cost and delay for smaller companies, which are the ones least likely to qualify for preemption, and that merit review substitutes a regulator's judgment for the investor's. Defenders reply that state regulators are closer to retail investors and handle a large share of small frauds that federal authorities do not pursue.