A dealer, in securities markets, is a firm or individual engaged in the business of buying and selling securities for its own account. The dealer is a principal in each trade: it owns the securities it sells and takes ownership of those it buys, and it profits or loses as their prices change. This sets it apart from a broker, who acts as an agent, arranging trades for customers and charging a commission without owning the securities.
Most firms do both, which is why the industry term is broker-dealer. A firm must tell the customer in which capacity it acted on each trade. Dealers supply much of the liquidity in bonds, currencies and derivatives, where trading largely takes place in the over-the-counter market and not on an exchange.
What dealers do
- Market making. A dealer acting as a market maker quotes a price at which it will buy and a higher price at which it will sell, and stands ready to trade at both. Its gross income is the bid-ask spread.
- Holding inventory. To fill customer orders at once, a dealer keeps a stock of securities, financed largely with borrowed money. Managing the risk of that inventory is the core of the business.
- Underwriting. In a new issue a dealer may buy securities from the issuer and resell them to investors, as described under underwriting.
- Facilitating large trades. A dealer may take the other side of a customer's block trade and work out of the position over time.
- Trading for profit. Dealers may also take positions on their own view of the market, known as proprietary trading, though banking rules restrict this for some firms.
Dealer and trader
United States law defines a dealer in the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 as a person engaged in the business of buying and selling securities for its own account. The same provision excludes a person who buys and sells for its own account but not as part of a regular business. Such a person is a trader. An individual investor or a fund that trades actively is therefore not a dealer, however large its volume.
The line is drawn by conduct. Indicators of dealing include holding oneself out as willing to buy and sell continuously, quoting on both sides of the market, having regular customers, and earning income from spreads or fees instead of from changes in value. The Securities and Exchange Commission adopted a rule in 2024 that would have brought certain high-volume liquidity providers within the definition, but a federal court set the rule aside later that year.
Regulation
A dealer in the United States must register with the Commission and join a self-regulatory organization, in practice the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority. Registration brings a set of continuing duties.
- Capital. The firm must hold a minimum of liquid net capital in relation to its obligations, so that it can be wound down without loss to customers.
- Customer protection. Customer cash and securities must be kept separate from the firm's own.
- Fair pricing. When it sells to a customer from its own account, the price, including any markup, must be reasonably related to the market price.
- Execution quality. The firm owes customers best execution of their orders.
- Records and supervision. Books, trade reports and supervisory systems are subject to inspection.
Separate regimes cover dealers in government and municipal securities, and banks that deal in certain exempt securities. Other jurisdictions regulate the same activity under the heading of dealing on own account as an investment service.
Special categories
A primary dealer is a firm approved to trade directly with a central bank and expected to bid at auctions of government debt. In the United States the list is maintained by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. In foreign exchange the term dealer is used for banks and for retail firms such as an authorized forex dealer. Swap dealers form a further registered category under derivatives law.
Conflicts and risks
Trading as principal creates a conflict of interest: the dealer gains from buying low from one customer and selling high to another, and knows more about prices than they do. Disclosure of capacity, markup rules and public trade reporting are the main responses. Dealers are also exposed to losses on inventory when prices fall quickly and to the withdrawal of the short-term funding that finances it. Since the 2008 crisis, higher capital requirements have reduced the inventory that bank-owned dealers are willing to carry, and observers have linked this to thinner trading in parts of the bond market during periods of stress.