What is Financial Distress?
Definition: Financial distress is a condition in which a company or household has difficulty paying its debts and other obligations as they fall due, or faces a high chance of being unable to do so in the near future.
Financial distress is the stage between ordinary financial health and formal insolvency. A firm in distress may still be operating and paying most of its bills, but its lenders, suppliers and owners can see that the business is under strain. It is a central idea in corporate finance, because the chance of distress, and the cost of it, shape how a company decides to balance borrowing against equity.
The term is also used of households that cannot keep up with mortgages, loans or card balances. For individuals the usual signs are missed payments, rising use of credit to pay for essentials and collection action. The rest of this entry deals mainly with companies.
Causes and warning signs
Distress can come from falling sales, rising costs, a failed project, or too much debt taken on in good times. High financial leverage makes a firm more fragile, because fixed interest payments must be met whatever happens to revenue.
Typical warning signs include:
- Weak or negative operating cash flow and a falling interest coverage ratio.
- Late payments to suppliers and shrinking working capital.
- A covenant breach on a loan, or a request for a waiver.
- A downgrade of its credit rating and widening credit spreads on its bonds.
- An auditor's doubt about the going concern assumption.
Costs of financial distress
Distress is costly even when bankruptcy is avoided. Direct costs are the legal, accounting and advisory fees of negotiating with creditors or restructuring. Indirect costs are usually larger and harder to measure. Customers hesitate to buy from a firm that may not honour warranties, suppliers demand cash on delivery, good employees leave, and managers spend time on survival instead of on the business.
There are also conflicts of interest. Shareholders of a distressed firm, protected by limited liability, may favour risky projects that could rescue the firm but would put creditors at greater risk, one example of agency costs. Alternatively, a firm may skip sound investments because the gains would flow mainly to creditors, a problem known as debt overhang.
Distress and the choice of capital structure
Interest on debt is usually tax deductible, so borrowing lowers a firm's tax bill. Against that stands the expected cost of distress, which rises with debt. The trade-off theory of capital structure says that a firm sets its debt at the point where the added tax benefit of one more unit of debt equals the added expected cost of distress. Firms with volatile earnings or assets that lose value in distress, such as brands and intangible assets, are expected to borrow less. The theory helps to explain why debt ratios differ between industries, though it does not explain every pattern.
Measuring distress
The best-known scoring model is the Altman Z-score, published by Edward Altman in 1968. It combines five accounting ratios: working capital to total assets, retained earnings to total assets, earnings before interest and tax to total assets, the market value of equity to total liabilities, and sales to total assets. In the original model for listed manufacturers a score below about 1.81 falls in the distress zone, and one above about 2.99 is considered safe, with a grey area between. Variants exist for private and non-manufacturing firms.
Market-based signs add to the picture, such as a debt ratio that keeps climbing and a bond price that falls well below par. No model is a prediction of failure, and each depends on the quality of the accounts.
Responses to financial distress
A firm has several routes. It can sell assets, cut costs or raise fresh equity, or negotiate with lenders for forbearance, a waiver or new terms. A debt restructuring may extend maturities, reduce interest or exchange debt for shares, as in a debt-for-equity swap. A wider corporate restructuring may follow.
If an agreement cannot be reached, a court-supervised process may be needed, such as Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the United States, which allows reorganisation under protection from creditors, or liquidation. Investors who buy the securities of such companies follow a distressed securities strategy. Households in distress usually negotiate repayment plans, seek advice or, as a last step, use personal bankruptcy procedures.
Ref 1010001624