An ESG index is a benchmark index constructed by applying environmental, social and governance criteria to a broader parent index of shares or bonds. Index providers use several methods, often in combination: exclusionary screening removes companies involved in activities such as thermal coal or controversial weapons; best-in-class selection keeps only the higher-scoring companies in each sector; and a positive tilt keeps most constituents but increases the weight of those with better ESG scores. Climate indices may also target lower carbon intensity than the parent.
Such indices are mainly used as the benchmarks for passive ESG funds and exchange-traded funds, and as reference points for active managers and structured products. The more an index departs from its parent, the higher its tracking error tends to be. Results depend heavily on the underlying rating data, which differs between providers, so two indices with similar names can hold quite different companies.