An economic moat is a lasting competitive advantage that protects a company's profits from competitors, in the way a moat protects a castle. A business with a moat can keep prices, market share or costs at levels that rivals cannot match, and so earn a high return on the money invested in it for many years. The term is used mainly by investors who select shares on the long-term quality of the underlying business.
The image was popularized by Warren Buffett, who from the 1990s described his preferred investments as businesses surrounded by wide and durable moats. It has since become a standard concept in value investing and in equity research generally. The idea behind it is older and comes from industrial economics, where the same thing is discussed as sustainable competitive advantage or as barriers to entry.
Why moats matter in theory
In a competitive market, high profits do not last. They attract new entrants and imitation, prices fall, and returns are driven down towards the cost of capital. A moat is whatever prevents or slows that process. A company with one can earn an economic profit, a return above what its capital providers require, over an extended period instead of briefly.
The length of that period is what gives a moat its value. Two companies may earn the same high return today, but if one can sustain it for twenty years and the other for three, the first is worth far more. Estimates of intrinsic value are therefore highly sensitive to the assumed durability of the advantage.
Sources of a moat
Analysts usually group moats under five headings, a classification associated with the research firm Morningstar:
- Intangible assets. Brands, patents and regulatory licences let a company charge more or keep competitors out. Each intangible asset of this kind may be worth far more than its balance sheet value.
- Switching costs. Customers stay because changing supplier would be expensive, risky or disruptive, as with business software or a bank's core systems.
- Network effects. Under a network effect, a service becomes more valuable to each user as more people use it, which favours the largest payment network, marketplace or exchange.
- Cost advantages. Economies of scale, a superior process or access to a cheap resource allow a company to undercut rivals or earn a higher margin at the same price.
- Efficient scale. A market is served by one or a few companies and is too small to reward a new entrant, as with a pipeline or an airport. In the extreme this is a natural monopoly.
A good product, a large market share, skilled management or rapid growth do not by themselves count. Each can be copied or competed away unless one of the structural sources stands behind it.
Measuring a moat
A moat cannot be observed directly, so analysts look for its financial footprint. The main evidence is a return on invested capital that stays well above the cost of capital through a full business cycle. Supporting signs include a stable or rising gross margin, steady market share, the ability to raise prices without losing customers, and consistent free cash flow. A high return for a few years is not enough, since it may reflect a favourable cycle or a temporary shortage.
Morningstar assigns listed companies a moat rating of wide, narrow or none according to how long it expects excess returns to last, and publishes a separate view of whether the moat is strengthening or weakening. This is distinct from the Morningstar rating for funds. Indices and funds are built from companies with wide ratings, which has made the moat a category of investment product as well as an analytical idea.
How moats erode
Moats are not permanent. The common causes of erosion are technological change, which can make a product or a distribution network obsolete, changes in regulation, the expiry of patents, and shifts in consumer taste that weaken a brand. Newspapers' hold on local advertising and fixed-line telephone networks are frequently cited examples of advantages that once looked secure and were lost.
A moat can also be damaged from inside, when management spends the profits it generates on unrelated acquisitions or lets product quality slip. And a dominant position may draw action under antitrust law, since the features that please investors, pricing power and the absence of rivals, are those that concern competition authorities.
Criticism and limits
The concept is criticized as imprecise. There is no agreed test for the existence or width of a moat, and judgements are often made with hindsight: successful companies are said to have had moats, and failed ones are said never to have had them. Ratings by different analysts can disagree.
A moat is also a statement about the business and not about the share. Companies widely recognized as having strong advantages tend to trade at high valuations, so that buying them may bring an ordinary or poor return. Value investors pair the idea with a requirement that the price leave a margin below estimated worth. Some investors, particularly in technology, argue that the pace of innovation matters more than any static barrier, and that looking for moats leads investors to underrate younger companies that are still building one.