A direct participation program (DPP) is a pooled investment vehicle in the United States that passes the financial results of a business venture straight through to its investors. The program itself generally pays no tax on its profits. Each investor instead reports a share of its income, gains, losses, deductions and credits on a personal tax return. The term direct participation plan is also used.
Most programs are organized as a limited partnership, though a limited liability company and other pass-through forms qualify. They invest in real assets and operating businesses, typically real estate, oil and gas, and equipment leasing. Interests are not listed on an exchange, so a DPP is a long-term and largely illiquid asset.
Structure
A limited partnership has two classes of partner. The general partner, usually the sponsor that organized the program, manages the business, makes all operating decisions and bears unlimited liability for the partnership's debts. The limited partners supply most of the capital. They take no part in management, and in exchange they have limited liability: they cannot lose more than the amount they invested or committed.
The partnership agreement sets out how cash flow and profits are divided, what fees the sponsor receives, and when the program will be wound up, usually after the assets have been sold some years later. Limited partners have rights to inspect records and to vote on a few major matters, such as replacing the general partner.
Common types
- Real estate programs. These buy or develop property such as apartments, offices and warehouses. They may aim for rental income, for a gain on sale, or for deductions such as depreciation.
- Oil and gas programs. Exploratory programs drill in unproven areas and carry high risk. Developmental programs drill near existing fields. Income programs buy producing wells. Tax law allows special deductions for drilling costs and depletion.
- Equipment leasing programs. These buy aircraft, containers, machinery or similar assets and lease them to users, earning rent and depreciation deductions.
- Other ventures. Programs have also financed agriculture, cable systems and film production.
Regulators treat a non-listed real estate investment trust in much the same way for sales practice purposes, although it is taxed under different rules.
Tax treatment
Each year the program sends every investor a schedule showing that investor's share of each item of income and deduction, to be included in the personal return filed with the Internal Revenue Service. Investors owe tax on their share of profit whether or not any cash has been distributed.
Before 1986, programs were widely sold as tax shelters, because early-year losses from depreciation and interest could be set against an investor's salary and other income. The Tax Reform Act of 1986 ended most of this. Losses from activities in which the investor does not materially participate are now treated as passive and can generally be used only against passive income, with unused losses carried forward until there is such income or the interest is sold. Separate rules limit deductions to the amount the investor has at risk. As a result, modern programs are sold mainly on their expected economic return.
Regulation and sale
Interests in a DPP are securities. A public program is registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission and with the states under blue sky laws. Many programs are instead sold by private placement, chiefly to an accredited investor. They are distributed by a broker-dealer whose representatives must hold an appropriate qualification.
Rules of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority require a firm to have reasonable grounds to believe that a program is suitable for the customer, taking account of the customer's income, net worth and ability to bear an illiquid holding, and that the customer has been told about the risks. The rules also cap the sales compensation and offering expenses that may be charged, and require an estimated value per unit to be shown on customer account statements. State regulators often impose minimum income and net worth standards and limits on the share of a customer's assets placed in such programs.
Risks and criticism
- Illiquidity. There is no public market. An investor who needs to sell early may find no buyer or only one offering a steep discount, and transfers need the sponsor's consent.
- High costs. Sales commissions, offering expenses, acquisition fees and management fees can absorb a substantial part of the money raised before any is invested.
- Conflicts of interest. The sponsor may earn fees whatever the outcome and may deal with the program through affiliated companies.
- Limited control and information. Limited partners cannot direct the business, and valuations are estimates until assets are sold.
- Concentration. A program usually holds a few assets in one industry, sometimes with heavy borrowing.
- Tax complexity. Tax schedules can arrive late, state filings may be needed in several states, and a sale can produce income taxed at ordinary rates through the recapture of earlier deductions.
Regulators have repeatedly brought cases over unsuitable sales of these products to retail investors, particularly older customers seeking income.