What is a Direct Commercial Sale?
Definition: A Direct Commercial Sale is a sale of defense articles or services made straight from a US company to a foreign buyer, with the US government acting only as export regulator.
A Direct Commercial Sale (DCS) is a transaction in which a foreign government or other approved buyer negotiates and signs a contract directly with a United States manufacturer or service provider, instead of buying through the US government. The export is lawful only if the State Department issues a licence or approves an agreement under the Arms Export Control Act and its implementing rules, the International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR). The supplier is the seller of record, takes the commercial risk of performance and is paid by the buyer under the terms of the contract.
A DCS is the alternative to Foreign Military Sales (FMS), in which the Department of Defense contracts with industry and delivers to the buyer under a Letter of Offer and Acceptance (LOA). Both routes derive from the Arms Export Control Act (AECA), and both are part of the family of programmes described in US Defense Article Transfer Programs. Many countries use both, choosing a route for each requirement.
How a Direct Commercial Sale works
The buyer issues a request to one or more manufacturers, negotiates price, schedule, warranties and support, and signs a commercial contract. The company then applies to the State Department's Directorate of Defense Trade Controls for authorisation. A licence for the permanent export of hardware is the usual instrument, while a technical assistance agreement covers defense services and technical data and a manufacturing licence agreement allows production abroad. Applications that exceed the statutory value thresholds are notified to Congress before approval, as described in US Arms Transfer Oversight and Technology Protection. The licence normally carries conditions on end use, retransfer and re-export, and the buyer is expected to sign end-use assurances.
The licence is separate from the contract. A contract that is signed but never licensed cannot be performed, so suppliers commonly make their obligations subject to export approval.
Comparison with Foreign Military Sales
The differences between the two routes lie in who holds the contract, who carries risk and what the buyer pays for. The main points are:
- Contracting. Under FMS the US government awards and manages the contract with industry. Under a DCS the buyer manages the contract itself and bears the burden of oversight.
- Pricing. FMS prices follow US government acquisition rules and include administrative charges. A DCS price is negotiated and may be more flexible, though the buyer does not benefit from the US government's purchasing power or its contract audit.
- Support. FMS can bundle training, spares and logistics under government arrangements, as described in FMS Delivery and Support Arrangements. A DCS buyer arranges support separately or in the same contract.
- Protection. FMS carries the government's contracting oversight, while under a DCS the buyer's recourse is to the supplier under the contract.
Payment and financing
Payment follows the commercial contract, commonly through milestone payments, advance payments secured by an Advance Payment Guarantee, or a Letter of Credit. FMS buyers instead deposit funds with the US government, as set out in FMS Payment and Financing Methods. Foreign Military Financing grants have generally been restricted to FMS, though for a small number of recipients the law allows the funds to be used for direct commercial contracts. Export credit support, where available, is a separate matter covered under Export Credit Agency (ECA) arrangements.
Offsets and oversight
Many buyers require the supplier to provide offsets, meaning commitments to invest in or buy from the buyer's economy. These are negotiated more freely in a DCS, since the US government does not itself take part in offset agreements, though it requires reporting of them. The subject is covered in Defense Industrial Cooperation and Offsets. Oversight of a DCS rests with the State Department, which monitors compliance with licence conditions and may investigate violations, and with other agencies that enforce the export rules, including the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) in criminal cases. Companies also face the anti-bribery rules of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) when selling abroad.
External links
Ref 1060000334