Commercial risk is the risk that a seller or lender suffers a loss because a private buyer or borrower fails to pay for reasons connected with its own business, rather than because of action by a government. In export credit insurance and official export finance, the term covers the buyer's insolvency, its failure to pay within an agreed period after the due date, and its refusal to take delivery of goods that were shipped in line with the contract. It is the main risk that trade credit insurance exists to cover. Export credit agencies classify private companies as obligors under corporate risk, a category kept separate from sovereign, sub-sovereign and bank risk.
Commercial risk is usually defined in contrast to political risk, which arises from acts of states: war, confiscation of assets, import bans, or restrictions on converting and transferring currency. Insurers and export credit agencies (ECAs) list the two groups of causes of loss separately in their policies, price them differently and sometimes pay out a different share of the loss for each.
Causes of loss
Credit insurance policies set out commercial causes of loss in a closed list. The usual ones are:
- Insolvency. The buyer is declared bankrupt, enters liquidation or a similar court-supervised procedure, or makes a formal arrangement with its creditors, so that the debt cannot be paid in full. The legal events that count are defined in the policy and follow the buyer's local insolvency law.
- Protracted default. The buyer simply does not pay, without any formal insolvency, and the debt is still unpaid at the end of a waiting period after the due date. This is known as protracted default.
- Non-acceptance of goods. The buyer refuses to take delivery of goods that conform to the contract, leaving the exporter with goods abroad to store, ship back or resell. Such a refusal, made without legal justification, is a form of repudiation of the contract by the buyer.
- Repudiation or termination. The buyer cancels the contract before shipment, causing a loss on work already done.
Losses caused by the seller's own breach of contract, by a genuine dispute over quality or quantity, or by exchange rate movements are normally excluded. Where the buyer disputes the debt, insurers usually wait until the dispute is settled in the exporter's favour before paying a claim.
Commercial risk and political risk
The line between the two matters most where the buyer is a state body or where a payment is blocked. If a private buyer pays local currency into its bank but the authorities do not release the foreign exchange, the loss is a transfer risk, which is political, not commercial. If a government buyer fails to pay, the failure is generally treated as a sovereign event, because a state cannot be put into insolvency in the ordinary way; insurers then speak of sovereign risk. Between the two sits public risk, the risk on state-linked buyers that lack the full backing of the state.
In the European Union, short-term commercial and political risks on buyers in member states and a small group of other high-income OECD countries are treated as "marketable". Private insurers cover them, and state export credit agencies may not normally offer that cover on the state's account. Longer risks, and risks on buyers in other countries, remain open to official support.
Assessment and pricing
For each buyer the insurer or agency sets a credit limit, the maximum exposure it will cover, after reviewing financial statements, payment history, trade references and reports from credit information agencies. The premium reflects the buyer's credit quality, the length of credit, the country, and the size and spread of the insured's portfolio of buyers.
For officially supported credits of two years or more, the OECD Arrangement on Officially Supported Export Credits sets minimum premium rates. Its premium rules combine the country risk category with a classification of non-sovereign buyers by credit quality, so that cover on a weak private buyer costs more than cover on the sovereign of the same country.
Percentage of cover
Credit insurance rarely pays the whole loss. The insured keeps a share, often called the uninsured percentage, so that it still has a reason to choose buyers carefully and to chase overdue debts. In short-term private-market policies, cover of around 90 per cent of the insured loss is common, with some policies set higher or lower. Export credit agencies have commonly offered similar or higher percentages on medium- and long-term business, and guarantees given to lending banks may cover a larger share of the loan. Exact figures vary by agency, product and buyer, and a single policy may set one percentage for commercial causes and another for political causes.
Managing commercial risk
Exporters reduce commercial risk in several ways besides insurance. They may sell under a confirmed letter of credit, so that a bank takes the buyer's place as the party that must pay; use a documentary collection to keep control of the goods until the buyer pays or accepts a bill; or sell receivables without recourse through forfaiting or non-recourse factoring. Each method moves some or all of the buyer's payment risk to a bank or finance provider, which takes on the commercial risk itself and prices it into its charges.
Banks that lend against credit insurance or agency guarantees still examine commercial risk, because the uninsured share and the policy's conditions can leave them exposed. A claim may be reduced or refused if the insured breached a condition, for example by failing to report an overdue payment within the time the policy allows.
External links
Ref 1170000202