A credit union field of membership is the defined group of people, and in some cases organisations, eligible to join a particular credit union. It is written into the credit union's charter and approved by its regulator. Only people within the field of membership, together with certain family and household members, may open accounts or borrow.
The concept puts into practice the principle of common bond membership: that members share a link such as an employer, an association or a community. It is most developed in the United States, where the National Credit Union Administration charters and supervises federal credit unions, and where the size and scope of fields of membership have been the subject of a long dispute between credit unions and banks. Other countries with credit union sectors, including the United Kingdom, Ireland and Canada, also limit membership by common bond, though their rules differ.
Legal basis in the United States
The Federal Credit Union Act of 1934 created federal credit unions and limited membership to groups having a common bond of occupation or association, or to groups within a well-defined neighbourhood, community or rural district. The NCUA sets out how it applies these words in its chartering and field of membership manual, which forms part of its regulations. State-chartered credit unions follow the law of their state, which may be broader or narrower than the federal rules. Because credit unions are exempt from federal income tax on the basis of their cooperative, not-for-profit nature, the breadth of their membership is closely linked to the debate over their tax-exempt status.
Types of charter
Federal credit unions are chartered in one of several forms:
- Single common bond, occupational. Members work for the same employer or in the same trade, as with credit unions serving a company, a school district or a military base.
- Single common bond, associational. Members belong to the same organisation, such as a church, labour union or professional body.
- Multiple common bond. The credit union serves several distinct groups, each with its own common bond, often called select employee groups.
- Community. Members live, work, worship or attend school in a defined local community, neighbourhood or rural district.
In each case the charter also usually allows family members of eligible people and certain organisations to join. A widely used rule, often summarised as once a member, always a member, lets people keep their membership after leaving the employer or area that made them eligible.
The 1998 Supreme Court case and new law
From the 1980s the NCUA allowed occupational credit unions to add many unrelated employer groups, so that some served hundreds of different firms. Banks challenged this in court. In National Credit Union Administration v. First National Bank and Trust Co., decided in February 1998 and involving ATandT Family Federal Credit Union, the Supreme Court held that the 1934 Act required all members of an occupational credit union to share a single common bond, which put many existing multiple-group charters in doubt.
Congress responded within months with the Credit Union Membership Access Act of 1998. It expressly authorised multiple common bond credit unions, generally limited new groups added to such a credit union to a size below a set number of members, protected existing members, and allowed credit unions to add underserved areas to their fields of membership. The same Act introduced prompt corrective action based on net worth and a cap on member business lending.
Expansion and disputes
Since 1998, many credit unions have converted from occupational to community charters or have added underserved areas, allowing them to serve large regions. Supporters argue this extends affordable services to underbanked people and strengthens small credit unions; banking groups argue it turns credit unions into tax-favoured competitors that no longer reflect a genuine common bond. Rules adopted by the NCUA in 2016 to widen community charters were challenged by bankers in court, and an appeals court upheld most of them in 2019. Disputes over field of membership also arise when credit unions pursue mergers, a subject covered under cooperative merger and conversion.
Other countries
In the United Kingdom, credit unions registered under the Credit Unions Act 1979 must have a common bond, for example of locality, employer or association, and are authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by both it and the Financial Conduct Authority. Legislation in 2011 relaxed the rules to allow mixed common bonds and corporate members. Irish credit unions, under the Credit Union Act 1997, are also organised around common bonds, mostly of locality or employment. Canadian credit unions are regulated by the provinces and are generally open to anyone in the area, so the field of membership is less restrictive there. Across these systems, the field of membership determines the potential size of a credit union and its scope for growth, in contrast with a community bank or other commercial bank, which can serve anyone. It also links to member-owned financial institution governance, since only members can vote.