The credit union net worth ratio is the main capital measure for federally insured credit unions in the United States. It is a credit union's net worth, made up mainly of its retained earnings, divided by its total assets. The ratio determines which of five capital categories a credit union falls into under the system of prompt corrective action (PCA), and so what actions the regulator must or may take when capital falls.
The ratio was set in law by the Credit Union Membership Access Act of 1998, which required the National Credit Union Administration to adopt a PCA system for credit unions comparable to the one Congress had imposed on banks earlier in the 1990s. It is a simple leverage ratio that does not weight assets by risk, although since 2022 larger, complex credit unions have also been subject to a risk-based capital requirement or an optional higher leverage ratio.
Formula and example
The ratio is calculated as:
- Net worth is mainly retained earnings, shown on a credit union's balance sheet as undivided earnings and reserves, plus a limited number of other items allowed by law and regulation.
- Total assets is the credit union's total assets measured on one of the bases the regulation permits, such as the quarter-end figure or an average.
A credit union with net worth of 120 million dollars and total assets of 1,500 million dollars has a net worth ratio of 120 divided by 1,500, multiplied by 100, or 8 per cent, which puts it in the well-capitalised category. If losses reduced net worth to 90 million dollars while assets stayed the same, the ratio would fall to 6 per cent.
Prompt corrective action categories
Under NCUA rules the categories are:
- Well capitalised. Net worth ratio of 7 per cent or more, and meeting any applicable risk-based requirement.
- Adequately capitalised. Net worth ratio of 6 per cent or more but below 7 per cent.
- Undercapitalised. Net worth ratio of 4 per cent or more but below 6 per cent.
- Significantly undercapitalised. Net worth ratio of 2 per cent or more but below 4 per cent. An undercapitalised credit union that fails to submit or carry out an acceptable restoration plan can be treated as being in this category.
- Critically undercapitalised. Net worth ratio below 2 per cent.
Credit unions that are not well capitalised must transfer a share of earnings to net worth each quarter. Those that are undercapitalised or worse must submit a net worth restoration plan and face restrictions on growth, member business lending and dividends, and the regulator may require a merger or, for critically undercapitalised institutions, appoint a conservator or liquidating agent. New credit unions follow a separate, more lenient schedule while they build up capital.
Risk-based capital for complex credit unions
The net worth ratio treats a residential mortgage and a commercial property loan the same way. To address this, the NCUA adopted a risk-based capital rule for complex credit unions, defined as those with assets above 500 million dollars, which took effect on 1 January 2022. Such credit unions must meet a risk-based capital ratio, similar in approach to the Basel framework used by banks, to be well capitalised. As an alternative they may opt into the complex credit union leverage ratio, a higher simple leverage test that replaces the risk-based calculation. This parallels the community bank leverage ratio available to smaller US banks.
Comparison with bank capital measures
Banks report several ratios under rules based on the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision framework, including Common Equity Tier 1 and total capital ratios measured against risk-weighted assets, as well as a leverage ratio. Credit unions cannot issue common shares, so their net worth is built almost entirely from retained earnings, which is why the measure is called net worth rather than equity. Low-income designated credit unions can include certain subordinated debt in net worth, but most credit unions cannot raise capital from outside. These constraints are part of the wider topic of cooperative capital adequacy and of bank capital adequacy more generally.
Limitations
As a leverage ratio, the net worth ratio is easy to compute and hard to game but ignores differences in risk between assets, interest rate exposure and liquidity. A credit union can be well capitalised on paper while facing large unrealised losses on securities or concentrated lending. Examiners therefore consider capital alongside other factors in the CAMELS rating used in a risk-based examination. Because net worth grows only through earnings, rapid asset growth, such as a surge in member deposits, can push the ratio down even when the credit union is profitable.