Transfer risk is the risk that a debtor who is willing and able to pay in its own currency cannot make the payment to a foreign creditor because the authorities of its country restrict or block the transfer of funds abroad, or because foreign exchange is simply not available. The debtor may have deposited the local currency with its bank, yet the money never leaves the country. Transfer risk is therefore a risk of the country, not of the individual company.
It is a core part of country risk, alongside sovereign risk and wider political risk such as war or expropriation. It is closely linked to convertibility risk, the risk that local currency cannot be exchanged into a foreign currency at all, and the two are often treated together as "transfer and convertibility" risk. Exporters, lenders, investors and correspondent banks all face it when they are owed money from abroad.
How transfer risk arises
Transfer problems usually follow a balance of payments crisis. When a country runs short of foreign exchange reserves, the government or central bank may ration access to hard currency, require approval for each outward payment, or impose exchange controls and wider capital controls. In more severe cases it may declare a moratorium on payments of external debt, including debt owed by private companies.
Such measures appear in many crises. Russia announced a moratorium on certain private external payments during its 1998 crisis, and Iceland imposed capital controls after its banking collapse in 2008 that took years to unwind. Less dramatic forms include long queues for foreign currency, rules requiring exporters to repatriate and convert their earnings, discussed under export proceeds repatriation, and official rates far from the parallel market rate, which make foreign payment possible only at a heavy loss. Each of these raises the cost and uncertainty of being paid from that country, even when the debtor itself is sound.
Transfer risk and convertibility risk
The two terms are often used together but describe different steps. Convertibility risk is the inability to turn local currency into foreign currency; transfer risk is the inability to move funds, even foreign currency already held, out of the country. A borrower holding dollars in a local bank account might still be barred from sending them abroad. A convertible currency can still be subject to transfer restrictions if the authorities choose to impose them. Convertibility risk is also called conversion risk, particularly in export credit and political risk insurance.
Rating agencies reflect this risk through country ceilings, which limit how high a company's foreign currency rating can be relative to the risk of transfer and convertibility restrictions in its home country. Companies with export earnings and offshore accounts can sometimes be rated above that ceiling.
Cover from export credit agencies and insurers
Transfer risk is a standard part of political risk cover. Export credit agencies include it in the political risks covered under export credit insurance and buyer credit guarantees, so that an exporter or bank is paid if the buyer deposited local currency but the funds could not be transferred. Private insurers write it under political risk insurance policies, often as currency inconvertibility and transfer restriction cover. Multilateral bodies such as the World Bank Group's investment guarantee agency offer similar cover to investors.
Claims usually become payable only after a waiting period, to separate a lasting block from a temporary delay, and the insured must normally show that the local currency was deposited in full. If transfers later resume, the insurer is repaid from the released funds.
Measuring and managing the risk
The OECD country risk classification, used by export credit agencies to set minimum premium rates, places countries in categories from 0 to 7 based mainly on transfer and convertibility risk and on force majeure. In the United States, banking regulators run the Interagency Country Exposure Review Committee, which assesses transfer risk in countries where US banks have significant exposure and can require special reserves for the weakest cases.
Banks manage transfer risk with country exposure limits, pricing that includes a country premium, and structures that keep payments outside the debtor country, such as offshore collection accounts for export proceeds or escrow arrangements. Trade finance offers some protection because short-term trade debts are often given priority when governments ration foreign currency. Restructurings through the Paris Club and the International Monetary Fund programmes that often accompany them have historically been a route back to normal transfers.
External links
Ref 1060000302