A carbon credit is a tradable certificate that represents one tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent (tCO2e) reduced, avoided or removed from the atmosphere by a specific project or activity. Credits are issued by a crediting programme after the project's results have been measured and checked by an independent verifier, and each one carries a serial number in a registry so that it can be tracked from issuance to use. Companies, governments and individuals buy credits to count those reductions against their own greenhouse gas emissions.
Carbon credits are often confused with emission allowances. An allowance is a permit to emit, created by a government under a cap-and-trade scheme; a credit is created by a project that cuts or removes emissions relative to a baseline. Both sit within the wider set of carbon pricing tools that also includes a carbon tax. The rules for credits come from international agreements, national schemes and independent standard-setters, and the market for them is split between compliance and voluntary segments.
How carbon credits are created
A project developer designs an activity such as a wind farm, a cookstove programme, forest protection, methane capture at a landfill or direct air capture of carbon dioxide. The developer applies a methodology approved by a crediting programme, which sets out how to define the baseline, how to measure the result and how to deal with risks. An independent auditor validates the design and later verifies the reported results, after which the programme issues credits into the developer's registry account.
Three tests shape whether a credit is credible:
- Additionality. The reduction must not have happened anyway without the revenue from selling credits.
- Permanence. Stored carbon must stay out of the atmosphere; forest credits, for example, can be reversed by fire or logging, so programmes often hold back a buffer of credits.
- Leakage. Emissions must not simply move elsewhere, which is why developers carry out a carbon leakage assessment.
Credits are also sorted into avoidance or reduction credits and removal credits. A carbon removal certificate records carbon taken out of the air and stored, and removal credits usually sell at higher prices than avoidance credits.
Compliance and voluntary markets
In compliance markets, credits are used to meet legal obligations. The Kyoto Protocol of 1997 created the Clean Development Mechanism, under which projects in developing countries earned Certified Emission Reductions that industrialised countries and companies in some trading schemes could use. Several national and regional schemes today allow a limited share of obligations to be met with approved credits.
In the voluntary market, companies buy credits to back climate claims, such as targets on the path to net zero. Independent programmes such as Verra's Verified Carbon Standard and the Gold Standard issue most voluntary credits, sometimes called a verified emission reduction. When a buyer uses a credit, it is permanently cancelled through carbon offset retirement, so it cannot be sold or claimed again.
Article 6 and the Paris Agreement
The Paris Agreement of 2015 allows countries to cooperate in meeting their national climate targets through Article 6. Under an Article 6 cooperative approach (Article 6.2), one country can transfer mitigation outcomes to another under bilateral deals, with a "corresponding adjustment" to the seller's emissions accounts so the same tonne is not counted twice. The Article 6.4 crediting mechanism creates a United Nations-supervised programme that is intended to succeed the Clean Development Mechanism. Detailed rules for both were agreed at the Glasgow climate conference in 2021 and developed further at later conferences.
Pricing and trading
Carbon credits have no single price. Value depends on the project type, the year the reduction took place (the vintage), the issuing programme, the host country, co-benefits such as community income, and whether the credit carries a corresponding adjustment. Most voluntary credits are traded over the counter between developers, brokers and buyers, though some exchanges list standardised contracts that bundle credits meeting set criteria. Some platforms have also issued tokenized carbon credits that represent registry credits on a blockchain.
Quality concerns and criticism
The voluntary market has faced sustained criticism. Studies and press investigations have argued that some forest protection projects used inflated baselines and so issued more credits than the real benefit justified. Critics also say that cheap credits let companies make claims of carbon neutrality without cutting their own emissions, which can amount to greenwashing. In response, standard-setters and buyer groups have published integrity principles and labels, and buyers increasingly carry out a carbon offset integrity assessment before purchasing. Supporters argue that well-designed credits channel private money to emission cuts and removals that would not otherwise be funded, particularly in developing countries.
External links
Ref 1180001631