The capital adequacy ratio (CAR) is a measure of a bank's financial strength that compares its regulatory capital with the riskiness of its assets. It is also called the capital to risk-weighted assets ratio (CRAR). Supervisors use it to judge whether a lender holds enough loss-absorbing capital to stay solvent if borrowers default or other losses occur, so that depositors and creditors are protected before any public support is needed.
The ratio sits at the centre of the Basel Accords, the international capital standards agreed by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision and applied by national regulators. It is one tool of prudential regulation and works alongside the leverage ratio, liquidity rules and supervisory review. Deposit-taking microfinance institutions that fall under banking law are usually subject to a capital adequacy requirement too.
Formula and worked example
The basic calculation is:
- is going-concern capital: common equity tier 1 (ordinary shares and retained earnings, after deductions) plus additional tier 1 instruments.
- is gone-concern capital such as qualifying subordinated debt and certain loan-loss allowances, which absorbs losses in a failure.
- are the bank's exposures multiplied by risk weights for credit, market and operational risk (see risk-weighted assets).
A bank holds 60 million in tier 1 capital and 20 million in tier 2 capital. Its loans and other exposures total 1.2 billion, but after applying risk weights its risk-weighted assets come to 800 million. Its CAR is . Its tier 1 ratio is .
Basel minimums and buffers
The first Basel Accord of 1988 set a minimum total capital ratio of 8% of risk-weighted assets, a figure that has survived every later revision. Basel III, agreed after the 2007–2009 financial crisis, kept the 8% total but tightened the quality of capital behind it. Its main elements are:
- A minimum common equity tier 1 ratio of 4.5% and a minimum tier 1 ratio of 6%, with the 8% total minimum unchanged.
- A capital conservation buffer of 2.5% of risk-weighted assets in common equity, which takes the effective total requirement to 10.5%; a bank that dips into it faces limits on dividends and bonuses.
- A countercyclical capital buffer of up to 2.5%, switched on by national authorities when credit grows too fast.
- Extra surcharges for global systemically important banks and, at national discretion, for domestic systemically important banks.
These are the minimum Pillar 1 standards. Supervisors may add bank-specific requirements under Pillar 2 after reviewing a bank's internal capital adequacy assessment, and many countries set national minimums above the Basel floor.
How risk weighting shapes the ratio
Because the denominator is risk-weighted, two banks with the same capital and the same total assets can report very different ratios. Cash and claims on many sovereigns carry low or zero weights, residential mortgages carry moderate weights, and unsecured corporate and retail loans carry higher ones. Under the standardised approach the weights come from tables set by the regulator; larger banks approved to use internal models estimate them from their own data, subject to an output floor introduced in the final Basel III reforms. A bank can therefore raise its CAR either by adding capital or by shifting toward assets with lower weights, which is one reason supervisors also watch the unweighted leverage ratio.
Capital adequacy in microfinance
When a microfinance institution is licensed to take deposits, it normally becomes a regulated microfinance institution and must meet a capital adequacy requirement. Microloan portfolios are small, unsecured and short-term, and experience in several countries has shown that repayment can collapse quickly when a crisis or a repayment boycott spreads through a client base. Guidance on microfinance regulation, including that issued by CGAP, has therefore argued that such lenders may need a higher minimum ratio than conventional banks. Some regulators have also set separate, simpler capital rules for small deposit-taking institutions, an example of proportionate regulation. Credit-only microlenders that do not take deposits are usually not subject to a CAR at all, although investors and raters still assess their equity and leverage.
Limitations
The CAR depends on the accuracy of asset valuations, loan-loss provisions and risk weights. A bank can report a healthy ratio while understating bad loans, and model-based weights have at times produced very low capital charges for assets that later suffered heavy losses. The ratio is also a point-in-time measure, so supervisors combine it with stress testing, liquidity metrics and on-site review. Published ratios under Pillar 3 disclosure rules let investors compare banks, but differences in national implementation mean that ratios are not always directly comparable across countries.
External links
Ref 1030000935