Prudential regulation is the body of rules designed to keep financial institutions, above all those that take deposits from the public, safe and sound, so that they can meet their obligations to depositors and do not threaten the stability of the financial system. Its core tools are requirements on capital, liquidity, asset quality and provisioning, concentration of exposures, governance and risk management, enforced through licensing and supervision.
It is contrasted with non-prudential regulation, sometimes called conduct regulation, which governs how institutions treat customers and the market, for example through consumer protection, disclosure and anti-money laundering rules. Prudential rules protect the institution and the system; conduct rules protect customers. Some countries assign the two to separate agencies, as in the United Kingdom, where the Prudential Regulation Authority handles the first and a separate conduct authority the second.
Why deposit-takers are regulated
A bank funds long-term loans with deposits that can be withdrawn at short notice. Depositors, especially small ones, cannot monitor the bank's risk-taking themselves, and a loss of confidence can lead to a bank run that spreads to other institutions. Public safety nets such as deposit insurance and central bank lending reduce the risk of runs but create moral hazard, because protected institutions may take more risk. Prudential regulation is the counterweight. It is usually applied at the level of each institution, sometimes called microprudential regulation, and is complemented by macroprudential policy aimed at risks to the system as a whole.
Main requirements
Prudential frameworks typically include:
- Licensing and fit and proper tests. Only authorised institutions may take deposits, and owners and managers are vetted, often through a fit and proper assessment.
- Minimum capital. An entry requirement in absolute terms, plus a capital adequacy ratio of capital to risk-weighted assets, and in many countries a leverage ratio.
- Liquidity. Requirements to hold liquid assets against short-term outflows, such as the liquidity coverage ratio.
- Asset classification and provisioning. Rules for classifying overdue loans and setting aside a loan loss provision.
- Exposure limits. Caps on large exposures to a single borrower or group, and on lending to insiders and related parties.
- Governance, internal controls and reporting. Board responsibilities, risk management, audit and regular returns to the supervisor.
International standards
The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, created by central bank governors of the Group of Ten in 1974, sets the main international standards for banks. Its capital accords began with Basel I in 1988, followed by Basel II and, after the global financial crisis, Basel III, which raised the quality and quantity of capital and added liquidity standards. The Basel Core Principles set out the minimum features of effective supervision and are used in IMF and World Bank assessments. The standards are not law in themselves; each jurisdiction implements them through its own legislation and rules, often with adjustments for smaller or less complex institutions.
Prudential regulation and microfinance
A central question in microfinance regulation is when an institution needs prudential regulation. The widely accepted guidance, set out by CGAP and others, is that prudential rules should apply mainly when an institution takes deposits from the public, because only then are small savers' funds at risk. Lenders that fund themselves with equity, donor money or wholesale borrowing can usually be covered by lighter registration and non-prudential rules on pricing disclosure, fair treatment and reporting.
Where microfinance institutions are allowed to take deposits, many countries have created special licence categories with rules adapted to small, unsecured loans. Examples include Uganda's law on microfinance deposit-taking institutions of 2003 and Kenya's Microfinance Act of 2006. Adaptations often include lower minimum capital than for banks but higher capital ratios, stricter provisioning for loans that fall into arrears, and rules that treat group guarantees rather than collateral as the main security. Supervisors must also weigh the cost of supervising many small institutions, which is why proportionate regulation is a recurring theme in financial inclusion policy.
Criticism and trade-offs
Prudential rules involve trade-offs. Higher capital and liquidity requirements make institutions safer but can raise the cost of credit and reduce lending, particularly to small firms and riskier borrowers. Complex rules favour large institutions that can afford compliance teams, and strict entry requirements can keep new providers out of the market. In developing countries, rules copied from international standards without adjustment may be poorly suited to local institutions and can push activity into unregulated channels. Supervisors therefore try to calibrate requirements to the size, risk and complexity of each type of institution.
External links
Ref 1210000545