Bank resolution tools are the legal powers that let an authority take control of a failing bank and restructure it without normal insolvency proceedings, so that essential services keep running and losses fall on shareholders and creditors rather than taxpayers. In the EU they are set out in the Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive (BRRD) of 2014; in the UK they sit in the Banking Act 2009, retained and amended after Brexit and run by the Bank of England (BoE); in the US the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) holds similar powers.
The main tools are sale of business, the bridge bank and asset separation, used alone or with bail-in. Two linked ideas shape their use: the critical functions that bank resolution must protect, and the rule that a bank needing extraordinary public financial support is generally treated as failing. Conservatorship is the US route for keeping a troubled institution alive under official control.
Sale of Business Tool
The sale of business tool lets a resolution authority transfer the shares of a failing bank, or some or all of its assets, rights and liabilities, to a private purchaser without the consent of shareholders and without following normal company law procedures. The sale must be on commercial terms as far as circumstances allow, and the authority usually runs a fast, confidential marketing process, often over a single weekend. In the UK the Banking Act calls it the private sector purchaser tool. The best-known example is Banco Popular, which the Single Resolution Board (SRB) resolved in June 2017 by writing down its capital instruments and selling the bank to Banco Santander for one euro. In the US the closest equivalent is the FDIC's purchase and assumption transaction, in which a healthy bank takes over deposits and some assets of a failed bank. The tool keeps customer services running with minimal disruption when a willing buyer exists.
Bridge Bank
A bridge bank is a temporary institution created and controlled by public authorities to take over the business of a failing bank until it can be sold or wound down. Under the BRRD and the UK Banking Act it is called a bridge institution; in US law the FDIC may charter a bridge depository institution under the Federal Deposit Insurance Act. The bridge receives deposits, critical operations and selected assets, while shareholders and the remaining liabilities stay behind in the old bank, which goes into receivership or insolvency. Bridges are meant to be short-lived: EU rules expect a sale or wind-down within two years, extendable in some cases, and the US statute sets a similar two-year term with limited extensions. In March 2023 the FDIC moved the business of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) into a bridge bank, which was sold to First Citizens BancShares within weeks.
Asset Separation Tool
The asset separation tool lets a resolution authority move impaired or problem assets of a failing bank, or of a bridge institution, into a separate asset management vehicle owned and controlled by public authorities. The vehicle then manages those assets with the aim of maximising their value through eventual sale or orderly wind-down, a structure often described as a bad bank. Under the BRRD the tool may only be used together with another resolution tool, usually bail-in, a sale or a bridge bank, so it cannot simply shift losses to the state while leaving the old bank untouched. The rule reflects concern that separating assets alone could give the bank an unfair advantage. In the UK the Banking Act includes an equivalent asset management vehicle tool. Moving bad assets out helps the remaining bank win investors' confidence and makes a sale easier, since buyers can value a cleaner balance sheet.
Critical Functions
Critical functions are activities, services or operations of a bank whose sudden stop would be likely to disrupt services essential to the real economy or to financial stability, because of the bank's size, market share or links with others, and because they cannot easily be replaced. The Financial Stability Board (FSB) set out guidance on identifying them, and the BRRD uses the concept. Typical examples are taking deposits, payments, clearing and custody services, and lending to firms and households. Critical functions drive the public interest test: if a failing bank has none, it can usually be wound up under normal insolvency law; if it has some, the authority will pick tools that keep them running. Planning for this is part of banking resolution planning, and arrangements such as operational continuity in resolution (OCIR) keep shared services available during resolution.
Extraordinary Public Financial Support
Extraordinary public financial support is state aid, or equivalent support from public funds or central banks outside ordinary operations, given to keep a bank solvent, liquid or viable. Under the BRRD and the UK Banking Act, needing such support is normally one of the signs that a bank is failing or likely to fail, which can trigger resolution. The rule aims to end the expectation that too big to fail banks will be rescued and to reduce moral hazard. There are narrow exceptions for a solvent bank facing a serious disturbance to the economy: state guarantees of new liabilities or central bank liquidity facilities, and precautionary recapitalisation, used for Monte dei Paschi di Siena in 2017. Where resolution funds are used, EU rules require a minimum bail-in of shareholders and creditors first, which is why banks hold MREL as loss-absorbing capacity.
Conservatorship
In US financial law, conservatorship is a process in which a regulator, or a conservator it appoints, takes control of a troubled financial institution to preserve and restore it as a going concern, running its operations and conserving its assets. It contrasts with receivership, where the aim is to close the institution and wind up its affairs, paying creditors from what is left. The FDIC can act as conservator for insured banks, the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) for credit unions, and the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) for the housing government-sponsored enterprises. The best-known case began in September 2008, when the FHFA placed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac into conservatorship during the 2008 financial crisis, with capital support from the US Treasury. Both remain in conservatorship, showing that the status can last far longer than first intended.
How the tools compare
| Tool | Who takes the business | Main purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Sale of business | Private purchaser | Fast transfer to a healthy owner |
| Bridge bank | Temporary public entity | Keep services running until a sale |
| Asset separation | Asset management vehicle | Remove bad assets, alongside another tool |
| Conservatorship (US) | Same institution under official control | Restore it as a going concern |
External links
Ref 1210000732