Variable universal life insurance (VUL) is a form of permanent life cover that joins two features. Like universal life, it lets the owner vary the amount and timing of premiums and adjust the death benefit. Like variable life, it invests the policy's cash value in a menu of investment portfolios, called subaccounts, chosen by the owner. The cash value therefore rises and falls with the markets, and so, within limits, can the amount paid on death.
Because the owner bears the investment risk, a VUL policy is a security as well as an insurance contract. In the United States it is registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), sold with a prospectus by representatives of a broker-dealer, and also supervised by state insurance regulators. It is used for estate planning, business succession and long-term saving by people who also need lifelong cover.
How a VUL policy works
Each premium, after any sales load and premium tax, is credited to the policy and allocated among the subaccounts and, usually, a fixed account paying a declared rate. A subaccount is similar to a mutual fund and is held in a separate account of the insurer, apart from its general assets.
Every month the insurer deducts charges from the cash value. The largest is the cost of insurance, which pays for the pure death protection and is based on the insured person's age, sex, health class and the net amount at risk, meaning the death benefit less the cash value. There are also administrative charges, a mortality and expense risk charge and the cost of any riders, and each subaccount has its own expense ratio.
The policy stays in force for as long as the cash value is enough to meet the monthly deductions. There is no fixed premium, but there is also no guaranteed cash value. If investment returns are poor or too little is paid in, the owner must add money or the policy will lapse. Some contracts offer a no-lapse guarantee for a set period provided a minimum premium is paid.
Death benefit options
Most policies offer a choice of two patterns. Under a level option, the beneficiary receives the face amount, and growth in the cash value reduces the insurer's amount at risk and so the cost of insurance. Under an increasing option, the benefit is the face amount plus the cash value, which costs more because the amount at risk does not shrink. Tax law also requires the death benefit to stay above a minimum multiple of the cash value, so a policy that grows strongly may have its benefit raised automatically.
Access to the cash value
The owner can reach the cash value in three ways: a partial withdrawal, a policy loan secured on the cash value, or a full surrender. Loans accrue interest and, with withdrawals, reduce the death benefit. A surrender in the early years is usually subject to a surrender charge, so the cash surrender value is less than the account value until the charge period ends.
United States tax treatment
A policy that meets the definition of life insurance in section 7702 of the Internal Revenue Code has three tax features. The death benefit is generally received free of federal income tax. Growth in the cash value is not taxed while it stays in the policy, and money can be moved between subaccounts without tax. Withdrawals are treated as a return of the owner's cost basis first, and loans are not taxed while the policy remains in force.
Two limits apply. If a policy lapses or is surrendered with a loan outstanding, the gain becomes taxable as ordinary income. A policy funded faster than the seven-pay test in section 7702A allows becomes a modified endowment contract: its death benefit keeps its tax treatment, but loans and withdrawals are taxed gains-first and may carry an additional 10 percent tax before age 59½. The death benefit can still be included in the insured's taxable estate unless ownership is arranged otherwise. The rules are administered by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).
Risks and criticism
- Investment risk. Poor returns reduce the cash value at the same time as the cost of insurance is rising with age, which can force higher premiums late in life.
- Cost. The layers of charges are higher than those of term life cover combined with a separate investment account, a comparison often made by critics.
- Complexity. Sales illustrations rest on assumed rates of return that are not guaranteed, and small changes in the assumption alter the outcome greatly over decades.
- Insurer credit. Subaccount assets are insulated from the insurer's creditors, but the death benefit above the cash value and any guarantees depend on the company's ability to pay.
Sales are subject to the conduct rules of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and to the SEC's Regulation Best Interest. The closest relative among savings products is the variable annuity, which uses the same subaccount structure without lifelong death cover.