Financial advice in the UK is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), and the way it is labelled and paid for was reshaped by the Retail Distribution Review (RDR), whose rules took effect on 31 December 2012. The RDR required firms giving investment advice to retail clients to describe it as either independent or restricted, banned advisers from taking commission from product providers on new advice, and raised minimum qualification standards for advisers.
The members of this family describe that framework. Independent and restricted advice are the two labels for a personal recommendation. Trail commission is the ongoing payment that the RDR stopped for new business. Targeted support is a newer, lighter form of help, introduced from April 2026, that sits between general guidance and full advice. All advice firms must hold the correct FCA authorisation, and complaints can go to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
Independent Financial Advice
Independent advice, in the sense defined by the FCA after the RDR, is a personal recommendation based on a comprehensive and fair analysis of the relevant market, and which is unbiased and unrestricted. The relevant market is the range of retail investment products that could meet the client's needs, not a single provider's range. An independent firm can specialise in a market segment, such as pensions, provided it covers that segment fully and makes clear to clients what it covers.
Independent advisers, often called independent financial advisers or IFAs, cannot be paid by commission from product providers on investment advice. Instead the client pays an adviser charge agreed in advance, which may be a fixed fee, an hourly rate or a percentage of assets, a model described under fee-based advice. The label is a regulated description: a firm that does not meet the standard may not call its advice independent.
Restricted Financial Advice
Restricted advice is any personal recommendation that does not meet the independence standard. A firm may restrict its advice to the products of one provider or a small panel, to certain types of product, or to a particular investment approach. Banks, insurers, building societies and many wealth managers give restricted advice, as do some firms that use only a selected panel of funds.
The firm must tell clients, before giving advice and in writing, that its advice is restricted and explain the nature of the restriction. Apart from that, the same rules apply as for independent advice: the recommendation must be suitable for the client, adviser charges replace commission on investment advice, and the adviser must meet the same qualification standards. Restricted advice is not necessarily worse than independent advice, but it is narrower, and a client cannot assume the recommended product is the best available across the whole market.
Trail Commission
Trail commission is an ongoing payment from a product provider to an adviser, taken out of the annual charges on an investment for as long as the client holds it. Before the RDR it was the normal way advisers were paid, and critics argued that it biased advice towards products paying higher commission and that many clients received no ongoing service for it.
From 31 December 2012 advisers could no longer receive commission for new advice on retail investment products, including investments held in an Individual Savings Account (ISA) or a pension. Trail on investments sold before that date, known as legacy trail, could continue, but it generally stops if the client receives new advice on the product or changes it. Separate rules phased out payments and cash rebates between fund managers and investment platforms by 2016. Commission remains permitted on some products outside the ban, such as protection insurance and mortgages. A client can ask the provider or adviser to switch off legacy trail.
Targeted Support
Targeted support is a UK regime that took effect in April 2026, after the FCA's review of the boundary between advice and guidance. It allows authorised firms to give consumers suggestions that are designed for groups of people with common characteristics, rather than a personal recommendation based on a full review of one person's circumstances. Its focus is pensions and retail investments, for example prompting people holding large cash balances to consider investing, or helping pension savers think about how much to draw.
Because it is not personal advice, targeted support costs less to provide and can reach people who would not pay for full advice. Firms must define the consumer segments carefully, check that a suggestion fits the segment before giving it, and remain subject to the FCA's Consumer Duty and to complaints to the Financial Ombudsman Service. The FCA's rules set out which products and situations are covered and how firms must present the support.
How the types compare
| Form | Personal recommendation | Market coverage | How it is paid for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Independent advice | Yes | Whole relevant market | Agreed adviser charge |
| Restricted advice | Yes | Limited, and disclosed | Agreed adviser charge |
| Targeted support | No, suggestion for a consumer segment | Set by the firm | Depends on the firm |
| Guidance | No | General information | Often free |
Advice on defined benefit pension transfers and on high-risk investment products carries further rules.
External links
Ref 1220000176