Synthetic risk transfer (SRT) is a transaction in which a bank buys credit protection on a portfolio of loans that it keeps on its balance sheet, passing part of the credit risk to investors in order to reduce its risk-weighted assets and the regulatory capital it must hold. The protection usually covers a mezzanine or junior slice of losses on the reference portfolio and is provided through a financial guarantee, a credit default swap or credit-linked notes.
The term overlaps with significant risk transfer, the regulatory test a bank must pass to recognise the capital relief, and the trades are also called capital relief trades or risk-sharing transactions. They are a form of synthetic securitisation, because the loans themselves are not sold. SRT is used mainly by European banks, where the framework is most developed, and increasingly by banks in North America and elsewhere.
How a transaction works
The bank selects a reference portfolio, often corporate loans, loans to small and medium-sized businesses, mortgages or consumer credit, and divides its potential losses into tranches. It usually keeps the first-loss or equity tranche and the senior tranche, and buys protection on the mezzanine tranche, which absorbs losses after the first loss and before the senior. When a loan in the portfolio defaults, the realised loss is allocated from the bottom up. Once losses reach the protected tranche, the protection seller pays the bank and the tranche's notional amount falls, in the same way as a principal write-down trigger works in other structured credit.
The bank pays a premium for the protection. The trade makes economic sense if the capital it frees, multiplied by the bank's cost of equity, exceeds the premium and transaction costs. Because the loans stay with the bank, its relationships with borrowers and its servicing of the loans continue unchanged, which is one reason banks prefer SRT to selling loans outright. Reference portfolios often contain hundreds or thousands of loans, and investors normally receive loan-level or pool-level data, along with the bank's own default history, so they can model expected losses before agreeing a price.
Funded and unfunded protection
Protection can take two broad forms:
- Funded protection. Investors buy credit-linked notes issued by the bank or by a special purpose vehicle. The proceeds are held as cash collateral, so the bank faces no counterparty risk on the protection seller, and losses on the reference portfolio reduce the principal repaid to investors.
- Unfunded protection. A guarantee or credit default swap from an eligible provider, such as a multilateral development bank, a public agency or a highly rated insurer, with no cash paid upfront. The bank relies on the provider's own credit standing.
Protection sellers include specialist credit funds, hedge funds, pension funds, insurers and development institutions such as the European Investment Fund.
Regulatory recognition
Capital relief is granted only if the risk transferred is significant. In the EU, the Capital Requirements Regulation sets tests that compare the risk-weighted exposure amounts passed to third parties with those the bank held before, focusing on the mezzanine and first-loss positions. Supervisors, such as the European Central Bank for large euro area banks, review transactions and can refuse recognition if the risk transferred is not commensurate with the capital relief. The European Banking Authority has published guidance and reports on the practice. Banks must also meet securitisation risk retention rules by keeping at least 5% of the risk, and since 2021 on-balance-sheet synthetic deals in the EU can qualify as simple, transparent and standardised, which lowers the capital charge on retained senior tranches.
Uses and risks
Banks use SRT to manage capital, make room for new lending, reduce concentrations and hedge credit risk on portfolios they cannot or do not want to sell. Supervisors and commentators have raised several concerns. The trades can make it harder to see how much risk a bank really keeps; they depend on accurate estimates of probability of default and loss; and investors sometimes fund their purchases with borrowing from banks, which can bring the risk back into the banking system. Features that could cut protection short, such as replenishment of the reference portfolio, early termination rights and a securitisation clean-up call option, are restricted under the rules. Growth in the market since the 2010s has made SRT a significant, if specialised, part of bank capital management.