Sustainable finance is the practice of taking environmental, social and governance considerations into account in lending, investment, insurance and other financial decisions, with the aim of supporting long-term economic activity that does not deplete natural resources or harm society. It covers both the management of sustainability-related risks, such as the exposure of a loan book to climate change, and the deliberate direction of capital towards activities with environmental or social benefits.
The term overlaps with ESG investing, climate finance, green finance and impact investing, but is usually the broadest of them. Its guiding reference points include the Paris Agreement on climate change and the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. Public authorities, standard-setters and market associations all shape the field, and rules differ significantly between jurisdictions.
History
Sustainable finance grew out of older ethical and socially responsible investing, in which religious groups and charities excluded holdings such as alcohol, tobacco or weapons. From the 1990s the focus widened to environmental reporting and corporate governance. The United Nations-supported Principles for Responsible Investment were launched in 2006, and the first labelled green bonds were issued by the European Investment Bank in 2007 and the World Bank in 2008. The adoption of the Paris Agreement and the Sustainable Development Goals in 2015 gave the field common targets, and in 2017 a group of central banks and supervisors formed the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) to study climate-related risks to the financial system. Since then sustainable finance has moved from a niche of specialist funds into mainstream regulation, bank risk management and capital markets.
Approaches and instruments
Financial institutions apply sustainability considerations in several ways:
- Screening. Excluding sectors or companies, such as thermal coal or controversial weapons, through negative screening, or selecting leaders within each sector.
- Integration. Including ESG factors in credit analysis, valuation and portfolio construction alongside financial data.
- Stewardship. Using shareholder voting and engagement to influence company behaviour.
- Use-of-proceeds finance. Raising money for specified projects through green bonds, social bonds, sustainability bonds and green loans.
- Performance-linked finance. Tying the interest rate on sustainability-linked bonds and loans to the borrower's progress against agreed targets.
Voluntary market standards underpin many of these instruments. The Green Bond Principles, first published in 2014 and administered by the International Capital Market Association, set out expectations on use of proceeds, project selection, management of proceeds and reporting. Similar principles exist for social, sustainability and sustainability-linked bonds and for green loans.
Policy and regulation
The European Union has built the most extensive regulatory framework. Its work began with the High-Level Expert Group on Sustainable Finance, whose final report in January 2018 fed into the Commission's Action Plan on Financing Sustainable Growth in March 2018. The main measures that followed include:
- The EU Taxonomy Regulation, a classification system defining which economic activities count as environmentally sustainable, an example of a green taxonomy.
- The Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation, which requires asset managers and advisers to disclose how they treat sustainability risks and to classify products.
- Corporate sustainability reporting rules that require large companies to publish standardised sustainability information.
Outside the EU, many countries have published their own taxonomies, and central banks and supervisors have begun to treat climate change as a source of financial risk, examining transition risk and physical risk through scenario analysis. Disclosure frameworks have converged around the recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, which the IFRS Foundation's International Sustainability Standards Board built on in its first standards.
Sustainable finance and financial inclusion
In developing countries, sustainable finance increasingly connects with financial inclusion. Inclusive green finance refers to financial services that help low-income households, smallholders and small businesses adapt to climate change, invest in clean energy or recover from disasters, such as loans for solar home systems, climate risk insurance and savings products that build resilience. The Alliance for Financial Inclusion and several central banks in Asia, Africa and Latin America have adopted policy frameworks on this theme. Blended finance is often used to make such investments viable.
Criticism and risks
The most frequent criticism is greenwashing: presenting products or companies as more sustainable than they are. Inconsistent definitions, divergent ESG ratings and limited data make claims hard to verify. Some commentators argue that exclusion and divestment change the ownership of polluting assets without reducing emissions, and that voluntary commitments by banks and investors have not been matched by changes in lending. In some jurisdictions ESG investing has also become politically contested, with arguments over whether it conflicts with fiduciary duties. Supporters respond that better disclosure and regulation are steadily reducing these problems and that climate and social risks are financially material in their own right.
External links
Ref 1180001710