Strong customer authentication (SCA) is the requirement, set by the EU's second Payment Services Directive and mirrored in United Kingdom rules, that a payer prove their identity with at least two independent elements from the categories of knowledge, possession and inherence before many electronic payments and account accesses. The detailed rules are in regulatory technical standards drawn up by the European Banking Authority, and in the United Kingdom they are applied by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Three concepts explain much of how the rule works in practice. Exemptions allow certain payments to proceed without the full check. Transaction risk analysis is the best known exemption, based on real-time scoring and low fraud rates. Out-of-band authorization is a common way of delivering the check itself. Each is covered below, followed by a short comparison. Thresholds are those in the EU standards, and the United Kingdom and other markets may apply their own variations.
SCA Exemptions
An SCA exemption is a case in which a payment service provider may skip strong customer authentication, because the risk is low or the check would be impractical. The main cases in the EU standards are low-value remote payments of up to €30, subject to a cumulative limit of €100 or five consecutive payments since the last authentication; contactless payments at a terminal, up to €50 each and with cumulative counters; payments to a trusted beneficiary that the payer has added to a list kept by their own provider; recurring payments of the same amount to the same payee after the first has been authenticated; transfers between a person's own accounts at the same provider; and secure corporate payment processes. Low-risk transactions can also be exempted by transaction risk analysis, covered below. A related page covers the SCA exemption in more detail.
The decision belongs to the payer's provider, the card issuer. A merchant's acquirer may ask for an exemption, usually through 3-D Secure 2, but the issuer can still insist on a challenge. Merchant-initiated and mail and telephone orders fall outside the rule instead of being exempted.
Transaction Risk Analysis (TRA)
Transaction risk analysis (TRA) is the real-time risk scoring of a payment that allows a provider to skip strong customer authentication when the payment looks low risk and the provider's fraud performance is good. It applies to remote electronic payments and works by assessing factors such as the payer's usual spending pattern, device and location, signs of malware and known fraud scenarios.
The exemption depends on two limits: the amount and the provider's fraud rate, which is measured over a rolling 90-day period:
For remote card payments, the ceilings are €100 where the fraud rate is at or below 0.13 percent, €250 at or below 0.06 percent and €500 at or below 0.01 percent. Above €500 the exemption is unavailable. Remote credit transfers have lower reference rates. For example, a provider that handled €400 million of remote card payments in 90 days, of which €0.4 million were fraudulent, has a rate of 0.4 / 400 = 0.1 percent. That is above 0.06 percent but within 0.13 percent, so it may use the exemption for payments up to €100 only. Providers using the exemption must monitor and report their rates, and have their method audited.
Out-of-Band Authorization (OOB)
Out-of-band authorization is the confirmation of a transaction or a login through a channel separate from the one in which it was started, such as a push notification to a registered banking app or an automated phone call. The payer sees the payee and amount on the second channel and approves with a PIN or a biometric. That approval can serve as proof of possession of the registered device, and it supports the rule that an authentication code be linked to the specific amount and payee, known as dynamic linking.
Its strength against phishing is that a fraudster who captures a password on a fake website still cannot approve the payment without access to the device. The limits are that the payer can be tricked into approving, as in authorized push payment fraud, that repeated prompts can wear a user down into approving, that codes sent by text message are exposed to SIM swapping, and that malware on the same phone can intercept the approval.
How the concepts compare
| Concept | What it does | Who applies it | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| SCA exemption | Lets a listed payment skip the check | The issuer, on its own decision or an acquirer's request | Value and counter limits |
| Transaction risk analysis | Exempts remote payments scored as low risk | Issuer or acquirer within its fraud-rate band | Amount ceiling up to €500 and fraud-rate band |
| Out-of-band authorization | Delivers the check on a separate channel | The issuer or its app | Approval obtained by deception |
Ref 1240000638