The stock borrow rate is the annualised fee a borrower pays to borrow shares, most often to deliver them in a short sale. It is quoted as a percentage per year and charged daily on the value of the borrowed shares for as long as the position stays open. In securities lending the same figure is called the fee rate or loan fee.
The rate reflects supply and demand in the lending market. Widely held, liquid shares that many institutions lend out cost a small fraction of one percent a year and are classed as easy to borrow. Shares that many investors want to sell short but few lenders hold can cost tens of percent or more and are classed as hard to borrow. Brokers publish indicative rates for each stock, which can change daily, and pass the cost through to clients who hold short positions. The broker's charge to its client usually includes a margin over the rate it pays to the lender, so the same stock can carry different rates at different firms.
How the fee is calculated
The daily borrow fee is the value of the loan times the annual rate, divided by the number of days in the convention year:
- is the value on which the fee is charged, often the collateral value of the loan.
- is the annual stock borrow rate as a decimal.
- is the day count basis, 360 for US dollar loans and 365 in some other markets.
In the US market, cash collateral is usually set at 102 percent of the market value of the shares, and brokers often charge the fee on that amount. Suppose a trader is short 1,000 shares priced at $50, so the market value is $50,000 and the collateral value is dollars. At a borrow rate of 20 percent, the daily fee is dollars. Over 30 days the cost is about $850, which the short position must overcome before it earns anything. Because the value is marked to market each day, the fee rises when the share price rises.
Rebate rate and negative rebates
When the borrower posts cash, the lender reinvests it and pays the borrower interest on it, called the rebate. The rebate rate equals a benchmark short-term rate, such as the federal funds rate, minus the borrow fee. For easy-to-borrow shares the short seller receives most of the benchmark rate on the cash proceeds. For hard-to-borrow shares the fee can exceed the benchmark, so the rebate becomes negative and the borrower pays the lender on top of giving up interest. Retail brokers usually show only the net cost, but the two views are equivalent. When the borrower posts securities instead of cash, no rebate is paid and the borrower simply pays the fee to the lender.
What moves the rate
- Lendable supply. Shares held by index funds, pension funds and margin accounts form the supply, while shares held in cash accounts or by insiders are usually not available.
- Short demand. Rising short interest pushes up rates, and heavily shorted stocks can see sudden jumps.
- Utilization. The utilization rate, the share of lendable supply already on loan, is a leading indicator: when it nears 100 percent, rates rise steeply.
- Corporate events. Dividends, votes, mergers, rights issues and lock-up expiries change demand to borrow and the willingness to lend.
Lenders can also change the rate on an open loan, a rerate, exposing short sellers to rate risk.
As a market signal
Analysts and academics treat high borrow rates as a sign of strongly negative views on a stock and of constraints on short selling. Some studies find that hard-to-borrow stocks tend to have low subsequent returns on average, consistent with prices staying high when shorting is costly. A combination of high rates, high utilization and rising short interest is also watched as a precondition for a short squeeze, since a recall or a rate increase can force short sellers to buy.
Limitations
Published rates are indicative and can differ between brokers, between lenders and over the course of a day. A low quoted rate does not guarantee that shares can be found, and in a stock with no lendable supply the rate is irrelevant because no borrow is possible. The rate covers only the cost of the loan, not the risk of recall, of a buy-in or of losses on the short position itself. Data on lending markets come mostly from commercial providers that survey agent lenders and brokers, and their coverage of smaller stocks and of borrowing outside the main lending programmes can be incomplete.