Specialty consumer reports are US reports on individuals that are compiled by companies other than the three nationwide credit bureaus, or that use credit data for purposes other than lending. They record specific histories, such as how a person has managed checking accounts, paid rent or filed insurance claims, and are used by banks, landlords, employers and insurers. Most fall within the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), the same law that governs the main credit report.
The FCRA treats any company that assembles such information for third parties as a consumer reporting agency. Users need a permissible purpose, consumers can see and dispute what is held, and anyone denied a product or charged more on the basis of a report is entitled to an adverse action notice. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) share enforcement.
Specialty Consumer Reporting Agency
A specialty consumer reporting agency is a company that compiles files on a particular aspect of consumers' lives rather than their general credit history. Examples include agencies that track checking and savings account histories, such as ChexSystems, which banks consult before opening accounts; agencies that report rental and eviction history; agencies that record employment and income; and agencies that hold insurance claim histories for homes and vehicles. Others specialise in medical or check-writing records.
Under the FCRA, an agency that compiles such files on consumers nationwide is a nationwide specialty consumer reporting agency and must provide each consumer with a free copy of their file once every 12 months on request, through a streamlined request process. Consumers may dispute inaccurate items, and the agency must investigate, generally within 30 days. Smaller specialty agencies are still consumer reporting agencies subject to accuracy, dispute and permissible-purpose rules. The CFPB publishes a list of the larger companies.
Tenant Screening Report
A tenant screening report is a consumer report that a landlord or property manager obtains on a rental applicant. It may combine a credit report or score, eviction court records, rental payment history, criminal records and identity checks into a single file, sometimes with a recommendation or score. Screening companies obtain much of the data from court records and other public sources and from landlords who furnish rental histories.
Because these companies are consumer reporting agencies, the FCRA applies. Applicants turned down, or asked for a higher deposit or co-signer, because of a report must receive an adverse action notice naming the screening company. They are entitled to a copy of the report and may dispute errors with the company, which must investigate. Mismatched identities and outdated or sealed eviction records have been frequent subjects of complaints and regulatory action. Some states and cities impose further limits, such as on the use of certain criminal or eviction records or on background check fees charged to applicants.
Investigative Consumer Report
An investigative consumer report is a consumer report in which information on a person's character, general reputation, personal characteristics or mode of living is obtained through personal interviews with neighbours, friends, associates or others who know the person. It is most often used in screening for sensitive jobs and occasionally for insurance. Reports built only from records and databases, or from simple verification with an employer, are ordinary consumer reports.
Section 606 of the FCRA sets special rules. The user may not obtain an investigative report unless it discloses to the consumer, in writing and within three days after the report is first requested, that such a report may be made and that the consumer may ask for more information. On a written request, the user must disclose the nature and scope of the investigation within five days. Adverse information obtained through interviews generally has to be verified again before it is reused in a later report.
Credit-Based Insurance Score
A credit-based insurance score is a numerical score calculated from information in a consumer's credit report and used by insurers to predict the likelihood or cost of future claims. It is mainly used to underwrite and price car and homeowners insurance. Unlike a lending score such as the FICO Score, it is designed to predict insurance losses rather than repayment, and it does not take income or the insured property into account.
Insurers using these scores are users of consumer reports under the FCRA. A higher premium or a refusal based on the score requires an adverse action notice, and the Supreme Court confirmed in 2007 that charging a higher rate can count as adverse action. Regulation comes mainly from the states: many limit how the scores may be used, for example barring cancellation or renewal decisions based on credit alone, and a few, including California, Hawaii and Massachusetts, bar or sharply restrict their use in car insurance. Critics argue the scores disadvantage low-income and minority consumers; insurers point to their predictive power.
How the reports compare
| Report | Main users | Typical content | Key FCRA right |
|---|---|---|---|
| Specialty agency file | Banks, insurers, employers | Account, claims or work history | Free annual file from nationwide agencies |
| Tenant screening report | Landlords | Evictions, rental history, credit, criminal records | Adverse action notice and dispute |
| Investigative consumer report | Employers, some insurers | Interview-based character information | Advance notice and disclosure of scope |
| Credit-based insurance score | Car and home insurers | Score built from credit data | Adverse action notice |
External links
Ref 1050000783