Risk budgeting is an approach to portfolio construction and oversight in which an investor decides how much of a portfolio’s total risk each asset class, strategy or manager may contribute, and then sizes positions to fit those limits. Risk is usually measured as volatility, value at risk or, for active managers, tracking error. The approach treats risk as a scarce resource to be spent deliberately, in the way a household budget allocates income.
Risk budgeting is used by pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, insurers, endowments and multi-asset fund managers. It complements traditional asset allocation, which is expressed in capital weights. Two portfolios with the same capital weights can carry very different risk, and risk budgeting makes that difference visible. Its best-known special case is risk parity, in which every asset class is given an equal share of total risk.
Capital weights and risk weights
A conventional balanced portfolio of 60 per cent equities and 40 per cent bonds looks evenly diversified by capital. Because equities are usually far more volatile than high-grade bonds, however, equities typically account for the great majority of the portfolio’s volatility. Risk budgeting exposes this concentration by measuring each component’s contribution to total risk rather than its share of money invested.
Measuring risk contributions
For volatility, the contribution of asset to total portfolio risk is:
- is the weight of asset .
- is the covariance matrix of asset returns and is the -th element of the covariance matrix multiplied by the weight vector.
- is the portfolio volatility.
The contributions add up exactly to , so each can be expressed as a percentage of total risk. This decomposition, based on Euler’s theorem for homogeneous functions, is the standard method.
Take a portfolio of 60 per cent equities with volatility of 15 per cent and 40 per cent bonds with volatility of 5 per cent, and assume for simplicity that the two are uncorrelated. Portfolio variance is , so volatility is about 9.22 per cent. With zero correlation, each asset’s share of variance is its own term divided by the total: equities contribute per cent of the risk and bonds about 4.7 per cent. Sixty per cent of the capital produces more than nineteen-twentieths of the risk.
Setting and using a risk budget
- Set the total risk level. The board or investment committee decides how much volatility, drawdown or tracking error the whole portfolio may carry, based on its objectives and risk appetite.
- Divide the budget. The total is allocated among asset classes, risk factors or managers, for example a share for equity risk, a share for interest rate risk and a share for active management.
- Size positions. Weights are chosen so that each component’s measured contribution fits its allocation. Leverage may be used to raise the risk of low-volatility assets, as in many risk parity strategies.
- Monitor and rebalance. Contributions change as volatilities and correlations move, so the portfolio is reviewed regularly and positions are adjusted.
In active management, a total tracking error limit is divided among managers or strategies, an application known as a tracking error budget. The budget is allocated in proportion to each manager’s expected information ratio, so that the most skilful managers are given the most room to take active risk.
Relation to other approaches
Risk parity sets equal risk contributions for each asset class. Equal risk contribution portfolios with many assets require a numerical solution. Risk budgeting is more general, allowing unequal budgets that reflect an investor’s views, for example a higher budget for growth assets. It also relates to factor investing, since budgets can be set for factors such as equity market, value or inflation rather than for asset classes. Measures of extreme loss, such as a tail-risk budget, extend the method beyond volatility.
Limitations
Risk budgets rely on estimates of volatility and correlation that can change suddenly, especially in a crisis, when correlations between risky assets often rise. A portfolio that looked well balanced may then become concentrated. Volatility also treats gains and losses symmetrically and can understate the risk of rare large losses, which is why many investors supplement risk budgets with stress tests and drawdown limits. Strategies that use leverage to equalise risk face financing costs and the risk of forced deleveraging. Finally, risk budgeting by itself says nothing about expected returns; an investor still has to judge whether each unit of risk is being well rewarded.