The Reves test is the method US courts use to decide whether a note, a written promise to repay money, counts as a "security" under federal securities law. It comes from the Supreme Court's 1990 decision in Reves v. Ernst & Young, which adopted what is known as the "family resemblance" approach. Under it, a note is presumed to be a security unless it closely resembles one of a list of familiar notes that are not, judged against four factors.
The question matters because both the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 list "any note" in their definitions of a security, yet many ordinary loans are documented with notes. The Reves test separates investment-type notes from commercial and consumer lending. It sits alongside the Howey test, which governs investment contracts, and both are used by the Securities and Exchange Commission in cases involving crypto products.
Background of the case
The case arose from the Farmer's Cooperative of Arkansas and Oklahoma, an agricultural co-operative that raised money for its general operations by selling uncollateralised, uninsured demand notes to members and the public. The notes paid a variable rate of interest and were promoted as an investment programme. When the co-operative filed for bankruptcy in 1984, noteholders sued its auditor, Arthur Young & Co., later part of Ernst & Young, alleging fraud under the Exchange Act over how the co-operative's accounts had been presented.
A federal appeals court held that the notes were not securities, which would have defeated the claims. The Supreme Court reversed, in an opinion by Justice Thurgood Marshall, and the case is reported at 494 U.S. 56.
The family resemblance test
The Court started from a presumption that every note is a security. The presumption can be rebutted if the note bears a strong family resemblance to a list of instruments that are plainly not securities, such as notes given in consumer financing, notes secured by a home mortgage, short-term notes secured by business assets or accounts receivable, and notes evidencing ordinary commercial bank loans for current operations. To decide resemblance, a court weighs four factors:
- Motivations. Whether the seller raises money for general business use or investment and the buyer seeks profit, such as interest, pointing to a security; or whether the note serves a commercial or consumer purpose.
- Plan of distribution. Whether the notes are offered broadly to the public for speculation or investment, rather than negotiated with a few sophisticated parties.
- Reasonable expectations of the investing public. Whether the public would reasonably see the notes as investments, for example because they were marketed that way.
- Risk-reducing factors. Whether another regulatory scheme, collateral or insurance makes the protection of securities law unnecessary.
If a note does not resemble a listed instrument, a court may use the same factors to decide whether a new category of non-security notes should be added.
Application in Reves
All four factors pointed toward a security. The co-operative wanted funds for its general business, and buyers wanted interest income; the notes were sold widely to thousands of people; they were advertised as investments; and they were neither secured nor insured nor covered by another regulatory regime. The Court also considered the Exchange Act's exclusion for notes maturing within nine months, a carve-out aimed at commercial paper, and a narrower majority held that it did not cover these demand notes.
Use in crypto and lending cases
Regulators have applied Reves to crypto lending and yield products, in which customers lend crypto assets to a platform in return for interest. In its February 2022 settlement with BlockFi, the SEC took the position that the firm's interest accounts were securities both as notes under Reves and as investment contracts under Howey, and BlockFi agreed to pay 100 million dollars split between the SEC and state regulators. The SEC used similar reasoning in its January 2023 action against Genesis and Gemini over the Gemini Earn programme.
Outside crypto, courts continue to use the test to decide whether loan notes are securities; in 2023 a federal appeals court applied it in holding that notes in a syndicated term loan were not securities. The approach also informs whether debt securities sold to retail investors need registration.
Criticism and limitations
Critics say the four factors are open-ended and give little certainty in advance, because similar instruments can come out differently depending on how they are marketed and to whom. Others argue that this flexibility is deliberate, letting courts look at economic reality rather than labels. For new products, issuers often have to analyse a single instrument under both Reves and Howey, and the outcome may also depend on state blue sky laws that apply their own tests.
External links
Ref 1210000533