Retention of title is a term in a contract of sale under which the seller keeps legal ownership of goods already delivered to the buyer until the buyer has paid for them in full. It is also called reservation of title or, in the United Kingdom and some Commonwealth countries, a Romalpa clause. The clause lets suppliers that sell on credit reclaim their goods if the buyer becomes insolvent, instead of joining the queue of unsecured creditors. Translations from continental European languages, such as the German Eigentumsvorbehalt, often render the same clause as retention of ownership.
Retention of title is one of the oldest forms of protection in trade credit, used alongside trade credit insurance, guarantees and letters of credit. It separates possession from ownership: the buyer may hold and use the goods, but legal ownership stays with the seller. How far the clause is effective depends heavily on national law, so the same wording can give strong protection in one country and almost none in another.
How a retention of title clause works
Ownership of goods normally passes when the parties intend it to pass, which in many sales is on delivery. A retention of title clause states a different intention: title passes only once a stated condition is met, usually payment of the price. If the buyer does not pay, the seller can demand the goods back and, where the contract allows, enter the buyer's premises to recover them.
Clauses vary in how much they try to protect. The main forms are:
- Simple clause. Title in the specific goods stays with the seller until those goods are paid for. This is the form most widely enforced.
- All-monies clause. Title stays with the seller until the buyer has paid every sum it owes the seller, not only the price of the particular goods.
- Proceeds clause. The seller claims the money the buyer receives on reselling the goods, often by requiring the buyer to hold the proceeds on trust.
- Mixed or products clause. The seller claims ownership of new products made from its goods, or a share in them.
The Romalpa case and English law
The clause became widely known after Aluminium Industrie Vaassen BV v Romalpa Aluminium Ltd (1976), in which the English Court of Appeal allowed a Dutch supplier to recover unsold aluminium foil and to trace the proceeds of foil that had been resold. Later English cases narrowed the effect of the extended forms. Simple clauses over identifiable goods are generally upheld, and the House of Lords accepted an all-monies clause in Armour v Thyssen Edelstahlwerke (1991), a Scottish case. Claims over proceeds or manufactured products, by contrast, have often been treated as creating a charge, which is void against a liquidator or administrator unless registered.
In practice, a seller relying on the clause must be able to identify its goods in the buyer's stock, which is why careful suppliers mark goods, record serial numbers and keep the goods separate where possible.
Effect in insolvency
Retention of title matters most when the buyer enters insolvency. Because the goods never became the buyer's property, they do not form part of the estate available to creditors, and the seller can ask the insolvency office-holder to return them. Many insolvency regimes, however, impose a moratorium that stops suppliers repossessing goods while a rescue is attempted, and office-holders may continue to use or sell the goods while the claim is resolved.
Buyers' lenders take a close interest in these clauses. A bank lending against inventory or holding a floating charge over a company's assets may find that a large part of the stock it thought it had is in fact owned by suppliers, which reduces the value of its secured position.
Differences between countries
National laws treat retention of title in quite different ways:
- Germany and much of continental Europe. Retention of title (Eigentumsvorbehalt in German law) is long established, and extended forms covering resale proceeds and processed goods are widely used.
- European Union. The Late Payment Directive requires member states to recognise retention of title clauses expressly agreed between buyer and seller before delivery, while leaving the details to national law.
- United States. Under the Uniform Commercial Code, a seller's attempt to keep title after delivery takes effect only as a security interest, which must be perfected under Article 9, usually by filing, to be effective against other creditors.
- Common-law countries with personal property registers. Australia, New Zealand and Canada also treat such clauses largely as security interests that must be registered.
Use in trade and credit management
Exporters selling on open account often include retention of title in their standard terms, but its value abroad depends on the law of the country where the goods are located, not only on the law chosen in the contract. Credit insurers may require the clause as a condition of cover or take it into account in recoveries. It is a different mechanism from a lien, which gives a creditor rights over goods it already holds, and from a pledge, which requires possession to pass to the creditor. Finance providers using invoice financing or factoring also check suppliers' terms, because a retention of title claim can compete with their own rights over the goods and receivables.
Ref 1210000503