A qualified mortgage (QM) is a category of US residential mortgage loan defined in Regulation Z that is presumed to comply with the federal ability-to-repay rule. Lenders must make a reasonable, good-faith judgment that a borrower can repay a home loan. Making the loan as a QM gives the lender legal protection if a borrower later claims that the assessment was not done properly, which is why most US mortgages are written to meet a QM definition.
The QM concept was created by the Dodd-Frank Act in response to the 2008 financial crisis, when many loans had been made with little check of income. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) wrote the rule in 2013 under the Truth in Lending Act, and it took effect in January 2014. A loan that is not a QM is not illegal: non-QM lenders can still lend if they meet the ability-to-repay standard directly.
Product features that are not allowed
A QM must avoid the loan features most associated with pre-crisis defaults. The core restrictions are:
- No risky payment structures. The loan cannot have negative amortization, interest-only payments or, except for certain small-creditor and rural loans, a balloon payment.
- Term limit. The term cannot exceed 30 years.
- Points and fees cap. Upfront points and fees generally cannot exceed 3% of the loan amount, with higher dollar or percentage limits for smaller loans that are adjusted for inflation each year.
- Income verification. The lender must consider and verify income or assets and debts, and, for an adjustable-rate mortgage, underwrite using the highest rate that can apply in the first five years.
Discount points that genuinely buy down the rate may be excluded from the cap within limits, and the definition of points and fees itself is detailed in the regulation.
The General QM definition
The original General QM required the borrower's debt-to-income ratio not to exceed 43%, calculated under a detailed appendix to the rule. A temporary exception, often called the GSE patch, treated loans eligible for purchase by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac as QMs even with higher ratios, and a large share of the market relied on it.
In December 2020 the CFPB replaced the 43% limit with a price-based test, effective from March 2021 with mandatory compliance from October 2022, and the GSE patch was phased out. Under the revised General QM, a first-lien loan of ordinary size qualifies only if its annual percentage rate (APR) does not exceed the average prime offer rate for a comparable loan by 2.25 percentage points or more, with higher thresholds for small loans and subordinate liens. Lenders must still consider and verify the borrower's debt-to-income ratio or residual income, but the rule no longer sets a fixed ceiling.
Safe harbor and rebuttable presumption
The legal protection depends on the price of the loan. A QM that is not higher-priced, broadly a first-lien loan whose APR is less than 1.5 percentage points above the average prime offer rate, receives a conclusive safe harbor: the borrower cannot challenge the lender's ability-to-repay determination. A higher-priced QM receives only a rebuttable presumption of compliance. A borrower can overcome it by showing that, at the time the loan was made, income and debts left too little to meet living expenses. The distinction matters most in foreclosure, where a borrower may raise an ability-to-repay violation as a defence.
Other QM categories
Several other routes to QM status exist. Small creditors that hold loans in portfolio can make small-creditor QMs with more flexible underwriting, including some balloon loans in rural or underserved areas. A seasoned QM category, added in 2020, lets a first-lien fixed-rate loan become a safe harbor QM after it has performed for 36 months in portfolio. Federal agencies set their own definitions for loans they insure or guarantee, so most FHA mortgages, loans guaranteed by the Department of Veterans Affairs and USDA rural housing loans are QMs under agency rules. Separately, the risk retention rules for mortgage securitisation use a closely related definition, so QM status also shapes which loans can be sold most easily into the secondary mortgage market.
Effects on the market
Supporters credit the QM framework with removing the most dangerous loan designs from mainstream lending: low-documentation and negative amortization loans, common before 2008, largely disappeared from the prime market. Critics argued that the original 43% ceiling and its detailed income rules excluded creditworthy borrowers with irregular income, such as the self-employed, and pushed volume towards loans eligible for the GSE patch. The price-based test was meant to address this, using the loan's rate as a proxy for risk. A non-QM market has grown for borrowers who fall outside the definitions, including those documenting income through bank statements, investors and borrowers with recent credit problems. These loans usually carry higher rates and are often sold into private-label securitisations rather than to the government-sponsored enterprises.
External links
Ref 1210000648