The ability-to-repay rule (ATR) is a United States regulation requiring a creditor to make a reasonable, good-faith determination, before making most residential mortgage loans, that the consumer has a reasonable ability to repay the loan according to its terms. The requirement was added to the Truth in Lending Act (TILA) by the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 and is implemented in Regulation Z at 12 CFR 1026.43.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) issued the rule in January 2013 and it took effect on 10 January 2014. It is closely tied to the qualified mortgage (QM) definition, which gives lenders a presumption that they have complied. The two are often described together as the ATR/QM rule.
Background
The rule responded to lending practices in the years before the 2007 to 2009 financial crisis. Many loans were made with little or no check of the borrower's income, a practice associated with reduced documentation loans and the wider growth of subprime mortgages. Lenders often qualified borrowers on a low starting payment, such as the teaser rate on an adjustable-rate mortgage or the interest-only period of a loan, rather than on the payment that would apply later. When payments reset and house prices fell, defaults and foreclosures rose sharply. Before Dodd-Frank, a narrower ability-to-repay requirement had applied only to higher-priced and high-cost loans.
Scope
The rule applies to most closed-end consumer credit secured by a dwelling, including first and subordinate liens on houses, condominiums and manufactured homes, whether or not the home is the borrower's main residence. Several categories are excluded, including home equity lines of credit, timeshare plans, reverse mortgages and temporary or bridge loans with a term of 12 months or less. Certain creditors and programs, such as some housing finance agency and nonprofit lending, are also exempt.
The eight underwriting factors
At a minimum, the creditor must consider and verify the following, using reasonably reliable third-party records such as tax returns, payroll records or bank statements:
- Current or reasonably expected income or assets, other than the value of the property securing the loan.
- Current employment status, where employment income is relied on.
- The monthly payment on the loan being made.
- The monthly payment on any simultaneous loan secured by the same property.
- Monthly payments for mortgage-related obligations such as property taxes, insurance and homeowners' association dues.
- Current debt obligations, alimony and child support.
- The monthly debt-to-income ratio or residual income.
- Credit history.
The rule does not set a single maximum ratio or minimum credit score. It instead requires a reasoned judgment and records showing how it was reached. For loans whose payment can rise, the payment must generally be calculated using the fully indexed rate or the introductory rate, whichever is higher, and on monthly, fully amortizing payments. Special payment calculations apply to interest-only, negative amortization and balloon payment loans.
Qualified mortgages and the presumption of compliance
A lender can satisfy the rule by making a qualified mortgage. A QM may not have negative amortization, interest-only payments or, with limited exceptions for small creditors, a balloon payment; its term may not exceed 30 years; and its upfront points and fees are capped. QMs that are not higher-priced receive a conclusive presumption of compliance, often called a safe harbor. Higher-priced QMs receive a rebuttable presumption, which a borrower may challenge by showing that the lender knew the remaining income was insufficient for living expenses.
The original general QM test included a 43 percent debt-to-income limit. Amendments finalised in December 2020 replaced that limit with a price-based test comparing the loan's annual percentage rate with a benchmark average prime offer rate. Loans outside the QM definition, often called non-QM loans, remain lawful if the lender complies with the ability-to-repay standard directly.
Enforcement and remedies
The CFPB, the federal banking agencies and state attorneys general can enforce the rule. Borrowers also have a private right of action under TILA. A successful claim can recover actual and statutory damages and an amount equal to the finance charges and fees paid, subject to limits. A claim for damages generally must be brought within three years, but a borrower facing foreclosure may raise an ability-to-repay violation as a defence by way of recoupment or set-off without that time limit.
Supporters credit the rule with ending the worst forms of unverified underwriting. Critics have argued that the litigation risk pushed some lenders away from borrowers with irregular income, such as the self-employed, and narrowed access to credit at the margins.
External links
Ref 1210000614