Price improvement is the execution of an order at a price better than the best publicly quoted price available when the order was received. A buy order receives price improvement when it is filled below the best offer, and a sell order when it is filled above the best bid. In the United States the reference quotation is the national best bid and offer, the highest bid price and lowest ask price displayed across exchanges.
The concept matters mainly for marketable orders, meaning a market order or a limit order priced to trade at once. It is one of the measures by which brokers and regulators judge execution quality, alongside speed and the likelihood of a fill. Its opposite, a fill at a worse price than the quote, is a form of slippage.
Formula and example
For a buy order, price improvement per share is the amount by which the execution price is below the best offer:
For a sell order it is .
- is the best offer and the best bid when the order arrived.
- is the execution price.
- is the number of shares or contracts filled.
Suppose a share is quoted at 20.00 bid and 20.10 offered, and an order to buy 500 shares at the market is filled at 20.08. The improvement is dollars.
A related measure compares the effective spread with the quoted spread. The effective spread is twice the distance between the execution price and the midpoint of the quote. Here the midpoint is 20.05, so the effective spread is against a quoted bid-ask spread of 0.10. The order paid 60 percent of the quoted spread; a fill at the midpoint would have paid none of it.
Where price improvement comes from
- Wholesale market makers. Most marketable orders from individual investors in United States shares are routed to a wholesale market maker, which fills them from its own account at or inside the quote. Orders from individuals are less likely to precede a sharp price move, so the dealer can afford to give up part of the spread.
- Midpoint and hidden liquidity. Dark pools and non-displayed order types on exchanges match buyers and sellers at the midpoint of the quote, giving each side half the spread.
- Exchange retail programmes. Some exchanges accept a retail price improvement order, a hidden order that trades only against retail flow at prices slightly better than the displayed quote.
- Auctions. Options exchanges run a short price improvement auction in which participants compete to better the price of a customer order before it is filled.
- Quote changes. An order may simply arrive as the market moves in its favour or meet a better-priced order that was not yet displayed.
Regulation and disclosure
Brokers owe customers a duty of best execution, which requires reasonable diligence to obtain the most favourable terms available. FINRA rules name the opportunity for price improvement as a factor that firms must weigh when they review order routing arrangements.
The Securities and Exchange Commission requires public reporting. Rule 605 of Regulation NMS obliges market centres to publish monthly statistics on execution quality, including the share of orders that received price improvement and the average amount. Amendments adopted in 2024 extend the reports to large broker-dealers and add detail. Rule 606 requires brokers to disclose where they send customer orders and what payments they receive.
A further rule bars quotations in increments smaller than one cent for shares priced at a dollar or more, while still allowing trades to be executed at sub-penny prices. This is why off-exchange dealers can improve on a quote by a fraction of a cent, while an exchange cannot display such a price.
Criticisms and limits of the measure
Price improvement statistics depend on the benchmark. The national best bid and offer has traditionally left out odd-lot quotations and all hidden orders, so a fill described as improved may be no better than a price that was available on an exchange but not counted. Reforms to market-data rules are intended to bring more odd-lot information into the published quote.
The link with payment for order flow is also disputed. Wholesalers pay brokers for the orders they execute, and critics argue that this money could otherwise have gone to customers as larger improvement, or that the orders would do better if exposed to competition order by order. Defenders point to measured savings for individual investors compared with exchange quotes and to commission-free trading. Studies have found that the amount of improvement differs considerably from broker to broker.
Finally, an average figure can mislead. Improvement is typically larger for small orders in liquid shares and may vanish for large orders, which can exhaust the quoted size and trade at worse prices. A complete view of an execution considers the whole order, not only the portion that was filled inside the quote.