A payment in lieu of dividends (PIL) is a cash payment made to the owner of shares that have been lent out, equal to a dividend paid on those shares while they were on loan. Because the shares were registered to someone else on the record date, the company's dividend went to the current holder, and the borrower of the shares must compensate the lender. The payment appears on brokerage statements as a credit to the lender and, where an investor has borrowed shares to sell short, as a matching debit.
PILs arise from securities lending, including the lending that brokers carry out with customer shares held in a margin account. Elsewhere, especially in the United Kingdom, the same payment is known as a manufactured dividend, and US tax rules call it a substitute payment. It should not be confused with a cash-in-lieu payment, which is cash paid instead of fractional shares after a split, merger or spin-off.
How a PIL arises
In a share loan, legal title passes to the borrower, who usually sells the shares, often as part of short selling. The buyer becomes the holder of record and receives any dividend from the company. The lender has given up the shares only temporarily and expects to be economically no worse off, so the loan agreement requires the borrower to pay an amount equal to each dividend. In practice the broker or lending agent debits the borrower's account and credits the lender's account on or around the dividend payment date.
Brokers may lend shares that customers have bought on margin, under the rehypothecation rights in the margin agreement, or shares that customers have agreed to lend in a fully paid lending programme. A customer may therefore receive a PIL without having taken any action, simply because the broker lent part of the position over the ex-dividend date.
Calculation and example
For an ordinary cash dividend, the payment equals the dividend the shares would have earned:
Here is the number of shares on loan on the record date and is the dividend per share. If 500 shares are on loan when a company pays a dividend of $0.80 a share, the lender receives , or $400, and the borrower is charged $400. The amount is normally the gross dividend; arrangements for any foreign withholding tax depend on the loan terms and the jurisdiction.
Tax treatment in the United States
The main practical difference between a PIL and a dividend is tax. For an individual US investor, a substitute payment is not a qualified dividend, so it does not receive the lower tax rates that apply to qualified dividends and is taxed instead as ordinary income. Brokers report it separately from dividends, on the form used for miscellaneous income rather than the dividend form. Suppose, using assumed rates for illustration, an investor would pay 15% on a qualified dividend and 24% on ordinary income. On the $400 above, tax rises from to , an extra $36.
Some brokers pay customers an additional amount to make up part of this difference, and some programmes avoid lending shares over dividend dates. For investors outside the United States, substitute payments on US shares are generally treated like dividends for the purposes of US withholding tax. Tax rules change and their application depends on circumstances, so the treatment of a given payment is set by current guidance from the Internal Revenue Service and the investor's own tax position.
While shares are on loan, the lender cannot vote them, because voting rights travel with legal title, so lent shares are excluded from proxy voting unless recalled before the record date. In return, the lender may earn a lending fee in addition to the PIL, and in a margin account the lending supports the broker's financing of the position. The borrower bears the cost of every dividend paid during the loan, which forms part of the expense of holding a short position alongside the borrowing fee.
- Substitute interest. When bonds are lent, the borrower likewise pays the lender amounts equal to the coupon payments made during the loan.
- Dividend equivalents. Derivatives that reference shares, such as swaps, often include payments tracking dividends, which some tax systems treat in a similar way to PILs.
- Corporate action compensation. For events other than cash dividends, such as rights issues or stock dividends, the loan agreement sets how the lender is compensated in cash or securities.