What is Net Operating Loss?
Definition: A net operating loss is the amount by which a taxpayer's allowable tax deductions exceed its taxable income in a year; under US tax law it can be used to reduce taxable income in other years.
A net operating loss (NOL) is a tax loss: it arises when the deductions a business or individual may claim for a year are larger than the income subject to income tax. Rather than being wasted, the loss becomes a tax attribute that can be carried to other years and deducted against their income. The rules are set mainly by Section 172 of the US Internal Revenue Code and administered by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). US states set their own rules.
NOLs matter most to startups, cyclical businesses and companies emerging from heavy losses, because they can shelter later profits from corporate income tax. The rules on how far and how fast losses can be used changed significantly in 2017 and again, temporarily, in 2020.
How a net operating loss arises
A tax NOL is not the same as an accounting net loss on the income statement. The two differ because of timing rules, tax-exempt items, faster tax depreciation and non-deductible expenses. A company can therefore report a book profit and a tax loss in the same year, or the reverse.
Corporations compute an NOL from their business income and deductions. For individuals, NOLs come mainly from business losses and certain casualty losses; most personal deductions cannot create one. Individual NOLs are reported through the forms and schedules covered in US individual tax rules and forms.
Carryforward and carryback rules after the 2017 tax law
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 (TCJA) reshaped NOL rules for losses arising in tax years after 2017:
- Carryforward without time limit. Losses can be carried forward indefinitely, replacing the former 20-year limit.
- An 80% limit. An NOL deduction for these losses can offset no more than 80% of taxable income in the year it is used, so a profitable company with large losses still pays some tax.
- No general carryback. The former two-year carryback was removed for most taxpayers, with exceptions for farming losses and for certain property and casualty insurers.
Losses that arose before 2018 keep the old rules: a two-year carryback, a 20-year carryforward and no 80% limit. For losses subject to the limit, the deduction in a year is:
Here is the NOL deduction for the year, is the NOL carryforward available, and is taxable income before the NOL deduction. A company with an NOL carryforward of $1,000,000 and $600,000 of taxable income before the deduction may deduct . Its taxable income falls to $120,000, and $520,000 of loss carries forward to later years.
CARES Act temporary changes
The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act) of March 2020 temporarily relaxed these rules. NOLs arising in tax years beginning in 2018, 2019 and 2020 could be carried back five years, producing refunds. The 80% limit was suspended for tax years beginning before 2021, so losses could offset all taxable income in those years.
Carrying losses back to years before 2018 had an extra effect: those years were taxed at the old top corporate rate of 35%, while the losses had arisen in years taxed at 21%, so the refund could exceed the tax value of the loss in its own year. The temporary rules have expired, and the TCJA framework applies to later losses.
Limits after an ownership change
To discourage buying companies mainly for their tax losses, Section 382 of the Internal Revenue Code limits the use of NOLs after an ownership change. Broadly, a change occurs when shareholders owning at least 5% increase their combined ownership by more than 50 percentage points over a testing period, generally three years. It is central to any acquisition of a loss-making company.
After the change, the NOL that can be used each year is capped at the value of the loss company's stock just before the change multiplied by the long-term tax-exempt rate published monthly by the IRS. For example, a company worth $50 million and a rate of 3% could use $1.5 million of pre-change losses a year, with unused amounts carried over. If the new owners do not continue the old business for two years, the limit can fall to zero.
Accounting for NOLs: the deferred tax asset
On the balance sheet, an unused NOL usually gives rise to a deferred tax asset, equal to the loss multiplied by the tax rate expected to apply when it is used. A $1,000,000 federal NOL at the 21% corporate rate supports a deferred tax asset of $210,000. Under US GAAP, a company records a valuation allowance against the asset if it is more likely than not that some of it will not be realized. Under IFRS, the asset is recognized only to the extent that future taxable profit is probable.
Because the asset depends on future profits and on the tax rate, changes in either can produce large swings in reported earnings. When the TCJA cut the federal rate from 35% to 21%, many companies wrote down their deferred tax assets. NOLs differ from capital losses, which are used against capital gains and underlie practices such as tax-loss harvesting.
External links
Ref 1010001566