Mutual fund transaction fees and share classes are the ways an investor can be charged, directly or indirectly, for buying and selling shares of a mutual fund. Some charges are set by the brokerage platform through which the fund is bought; others are built into the fund's own share classes, which hold the same portfolio but carry different sales charges and ongoing fees.
This page covers three related terms. A no-transaction-fee fund can be traded on a platform without a commission, while a transaction-fee fund incurs one. Class B shares are a fund-level share class that replaced an up-front sales charge with a deferred one. All three sit alongside the sales charges described in Mutual Fund Loads (Front-End, Back-End and No-Load) and the fund's expense ratio, and they explain why the same fund can cost different amounts on different platforms.
No-Transaction-Fee (NTF) Fund
A no-transaction-fee (NTF) fund is a mutual fund that a brokerage allows its clients to buy and sell without paying the platform's usual transaction charge. NTF lists are set by each broker and can include both the broker's own funds and funds from outside managers that have agreed to take part.
The broker is not working for nothing: it is usually paid by the fund or its manager through arrangements such as 12b-1 fees, shareholder servicing payments and revenue sharing. Those costs can be reflected in a higher expense ratio for the share class offered, so an NTF fund is not always the cheapest option over a long holding period. Platforms often charge a short-term trading fee if an NTF fund is sold within a set number of days of purchase, to discourage rapid trading, and the fund may also impose its own redemption fee. NTF status depends on the platform, not the fund: the same fund may be NTF at one broker and carry a fee at another.
Transaction-Fee Fund
A transaction-fee fund is a mutual fund for which a brokerage charges a fee each time a client buys, and sometimes sells, its shares. The fee is typically a flat dollar amount per trade, set out in the broker's fee schedule, and is paid from the client's brokerage account in addition to the amount invested.
The charge is a platform fee, separate from anything the fund itself levies. It is not a sales load, which is paid to compensate the selling intermediary and is described in the prospectus, and it is not part of the expense ratio, which is taken from fund assets every year. Funds usually fall into the transaction-fee category when their sponsors do not pay the broker to be on its NTF list. Such funds may offer lower-cost share classes, so for a large purchase held for many years a one-off fee can cost less overall than the ongoing fees embedded in an NTF alternative. Some brokers waive or reduce the fee for automatic investment plans.
Class B shares are a mutual fund share class sold without an up-front sales charge but with a contingent deferred sales charge (CDSC) payable if the shares are sold within a set number of years. The CDSC typically starts at around 5% in the first year and steps down each year until it reaches zero after about six years. In return for the absence of a front load, B shares carry higher annual distribution fees, usually the maximum 12b-1 fee of 1% of assets, and they automatically convert to the fund's Class A shares, with their lower ongoing fees, after a period such as eight years.
B shares were criticized because they offered no breakpoint discounts, so large purchases were usually cheaper in A shares, and regulators including FINRA brought cases over unsuitable B-share sales. Most US fund families have since closed B shares to new investment, and existing holdings continue to age out through share class conversion.
How the charges compare
| Item | Who sets it | When it is paid | How it is paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| NTF fund | Brokerage platform | No trade fee; short-term fee may apply | Indirectly, through fund payments to the broker |
| Transaction-fee fund | Brokerage platform | At purchase and sometimes at sale | Flat fee from the brokerage account |
| Class B shares | Fund prospectus | At sale within the CDSC period; 12b-1 fee yearly | Deducted from sale proceeds and fund assets |
Ref 1180001939